Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich Recipe

Note- This post may contain affiliate links, we earn from qualifying purchases made on our website. If you make a purchase through links from this website, we may get a small share of the sale from Amazon and other similar affiliate programs.

I am sure you may have heard of a zesty garden turkey club sandwich somewhere. Is this the same sandwich that was launched by Jimmy John’s a little while earlier this year? It sure is! Let’s take a look at how exactly you can make this sandwich! 

Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich

Anyone who loves sandwiches from Jimmy John’s would know that they keep coming up with new sandwiches every now and then. Most of their sandwiches are always zesty, considering all the herb aioli they add to them! 

So, it truly is an experience to eat their sandwiches. The zesty garden turkey club was introduced on their menu earlier this year and was surely a huge hit! So, now that Thanksgiving is coming up soon and it is the perfect time to indulge in turkey in general, you can recreate this exceptionally easy and delicious sandwich at home! 

Let me tell you this; the sandwich won’t exactly taste like how you find it at Jimmy John’s. But, it still is as much of an accurate recreation of the same, with a little twist of mine that I’m sure you will really love! So, be ready to use some of your Thanksgiving leftover turkeys in the best way possible! 

In this recipe, you will find a step-by-step guide on how to make this zesty garden turkey club sandwich, starting off with the equipment needed for it to the ingredients, method, and also nutritional information. So, let’s get started with the recipe, and happy reading to you! 

Other Thanksgiving Recipes That You Can Try

What Equipment Will You Need To Make a Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich? 

  • Spoon – Starting with the most basic yet important equipment of them all, you will need a couple of spoons to make a zesty herb aioli. As we aren’t baking here, and you can tweak the amount of ingredients as per your personal flavor preferences, you can use a set of regular teaspoons and tablespoons from your kitchen. 
  • Bowl – You will need a large bowl to make your herb aioli. Just one of them will do for this recipe. 
  • Knife – You will need a large knife to slice your tomatoes thinly and also the turkey, in case you are using leftover turkey that hasn’t been carved yet. 
  • Cutting Board – A large and sturdy cutting board will be needed to slice your tomatoes and turkey and also cut the sandwich in half right before you serve it. 
  • Whisk – You will need a whisk to make your herb aioli. You can use a spoon. However, a whisk is surely better equipment considering the fact that it will break all the lumps and make the mix quite easy. 
  • Skillet – Now, this equipment is actually optional for this sandwich. The reason behind that is just the fact that the sandwich does not necessarily have to be toasted. You can have it just as it is or toasts it in a cast iron skillet if you would like to. 

How Much Time Will You Need To Make A Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich? 

Preparation TimeCooking TimeTotal Time
15 Minutes5 Minutes20 Minutes

What Ingredients Will You Need To Make A Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich? 

For The Sandwich :

  • Turkey – For this sandwich, you can very well use leftover turkey from Thanksgiving. In case you don’t have any of that, you can also use fresh turkey slices bought from a deli if you would like. You will need 2 ounces of turkey for a single sandwich. 
  • Romaine Lettuce – You will need two leaves of romaine lettuce for one sandwich. Here, if you cannot find romaine lettuce, you can instead use butterhead lettuce too. Just try not to go for iceberg lettuce, as it lacks flavor compared to the other two types that I have mentioned. 
  • Herb Aioli – For this sandwich, you will have to make a herb aioli of your own. Don’t worry; it’s exceptionally easy and will barely take any time. You will need two tablespoons of the same, and the ingredients needed to make the aioli are given later in this article. 
  • Whole Grain Bread – Whole grain bread is the perfect option for this sandwich, just considering how well it goes with each ingredient. You will require two slices of the same for a single sandwich. 
  • Tomatoes – You will need a single small tomato for this sandwich. 

For The Herb Aioli :

  • Mayonnaise – The base of the herb aioli is mayonnaise. You will need ¼ cup of mayonnaise to get a yield of ½ cup of herb aioli, which can be stored and used later too. 
  • Parsley – You will need two tablespoons of freshly chopped parsley for this recipe. It surely will add a lot of flavors, but you can choose to skip it if you don’t like parsley. 
  • Garlic – You will need a single clove of garlic chopped into tiny pieces for this aioli recipe. 
  • Dill – Dill will again add a great flavor to the aioli, so you will need two tablespoons of the same for this recipe. 
  • White Wine Vinegar – The vinegar will truly give this aioli the zesty flavor that it needs! You will need just half a teaspoon of the same to make the herb aioli. 
  • Hot Sauce – Again, hot sauce will add zest and a ton of flavor to the herb aioli recipe, so you will need half a teaspoon of the same. 
  • Salt – Lastly, to enhance all the flavorings added to the herb aioli, you will need ½ a teaspoon of any form of salt as per your liking. 
Zesty Garden Turkey Club 1

Steps To Make Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich

1. Make The Herb Aioli

The first step while making this sandwich is to make the herb aioli. This can also be done way ahead of time and stored for later use if you would like. Making the herb aioli is simply one single step. 

Take the mayonnaise, garlic, dill, parsley, vinegar, hot sauce, and salt in a large bowl and whisk together. Once everything is combined together, transfer the aioli to an airtight container and store it in the refrigerator until ready to use. Also, thinly slice the tomato and keep it aside to use for the sandwich. 

2. Assemble The Sandwich

Once the herb aioli is ready, you can start assembling the sandwich. For that, if you would like your bread to be toasted and crispy, start by toasting your bread in a skillet or a toaster if you would like. Ideally, there is no need to add any extra fat like butter since the aioli makes up for it. 

However, if you would like to use some butter while toasting your bread, you can. You can also skip toasting the bread if you like, as it isn’t really necessary. Once your bread slices are ready, spread some of the herb aioli on both slices, and on one of them, place one leaf of lettuce, then the tomato, and finally, the turkey slices.

Top the turkey slices with the second leaf of lettuce, and then top it with the other slice of bread that has herb aioli spread on it, with the aioli side facing inside. Slice the sandwich diagonally in half and serve with your favorite sides! 

What Can Be Served With The Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich? 

  • Sweet Potato Fries – Sweet potato fries are gaining popularity as a side and for all the right reasons! These fries will make a great accompaniment to your sandwich and complement the flavors perfectly. 
  • French Fries – If you don’t like sweet potato fries, you can also serve regular french fries with your sandwich. Alternatively, you can serve cajun fries, too, as they will also work exceptionally well. 
  • Potato Chips – Potato chips are the perfect accompaniment to a hearty sandwich and, in this case, will fit perfectly with the zesty garden club sandwich! 
  • Cheesy Fries – If you are feeling a little adventurous and extra indulgent, you can go ahead and serve cheesy fries with this club sandwich. For extra indulgence and flavor, you can also add some bacon bits on top. 
  • Side Salad – In case you want to keep the side option a little light, then a side salad with a simple vinaigrette dressing is a good option to serve with the club sandwich. 
  • Zucchini Fries – Zucchini fries are absolutely delicious and a great substitute for regular french fries if you wouldn’t want your meal to be too starchy. 

What Variations Can Be Made With The Zesty Garden Turkey Club? 

  • Replace The Romaine Lettuce – There are a number of greens that can be used in place of romaine lettuce if you would like! Butterhead lettuce, as I mentioned earlier, is a great option. Spinach or baby spinach leaves also make a great leafy addition. 
  • Mustard To The Herb Aioli – If you want an extra zesty and zingy flavor in your mayonnaise, you can add half a teaspoon of yellow or Dijon mustard to the same. 
  • Add Cheese – To make the sandwich extra cheesy and indulgent, you can add a few slices of cheddar or Monterey jack cheese to the sandwich. 
  • Toast The Sandwich – This method particularly works well if you decide to add extra cheese to your sandwich. For this, skip toasting the bread initially; instead, you can toast the sandwich in a skillet or panini press once it has been assembled. This way, the cheese will get all gooey and delicious. 
  • Add Bacon – Bacon does make everything better with its savory flavor! So, you can fry some bacon and add it to this sandwich, too, if you would like. 

Nutritional Information

Calories320 kcal
Carbohydrates41 grams
Protein23 grams
Fat9 grams
Saturated Fats2 grams
Cholesterol50 milligrams
Sodium1310 milligrams
Potassium491 milligrams
Fiber7 grams
Sugar3 grams
Vitamin A5680 micrograms
Vitamin C16 milligrams
Calcium140 milligrams
Iron 3 milligrams

What Will The Zesty Turkey Club Sandwich Look And Taste Like? 

Here, you may wonder if the sandwich is actually supposed to look exactly like the sandwich from Jimmy John’s. But, as I said earlier, this sandwich is not an exact copy of the original but an equally delicious version of the same sandwich. 

Starting off with the way the sandwich will look, it will look like a sandwich from a deli or a diner, for sure. Packed with the goodness of a heap of turkey and also all the veggies, this sandwich is big and hearty and surely a mouthful! 

The flavor of the sandwich is also truly impeccable. The herb aioli has a zesty flavor to it, coming from the hot sauce and vinegar and also the rest of the ingredients, while still keeping the creamy flavor of mayonnaise intact. Combined with the toasted bread, it surely creates a lot of textures and flavors that work really well together. 

Recipe Card

Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich 2

Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich Recipe

Zesty garden turkey club sandwich is the perfect combination of leftover turkey, mixed with veggies and a zesty herb aioli. Moreover, this recipe will take barely any time to put together!
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 15 mins
Cook Time 5 mins
Total Time 20 mins
Course Brunch, Dinner, Lunch
Cuisine American
Servings 1 Serving
Calories 320 kcal


Cutting Board


For The Sandwich

  • 2 ounces Cooked Turkey
  • 2 leaves Romaine Lettuce
  • 2 slices Whole Grain Bread
  • 1 no. Tomato
  • 2 tablespoons Herb Aioli

For The Herb Aioli

  • 1/4 cup Mayonnaise
  • 2 tablespoons Parsley (chopped)
  • 1 clove Garlic (minced)
  • 2 tablespoons Dill (chopped)
  • 1/2 teaspoon White Wine Vinegar
  • 1/2 teaspoon Hot Sauce
  • 1/2 teaspoon Salt


For The Herb Aioli

  • In a large bowl, add the mayonnaise, parsley, garlic, dill, vinegar, hot sauce and salt.
  • Whisk till everything is well combined.
  • Transfer to an airtight container and store in the refrigerator until ready to use.

For The Sandwich

  • Toast the bread slices lightly in the skillet.
  • Spread herb aioli on one side of both slices.
  • On one of the slices, place one lettuce leaf, tomato and finally, the turkey.
  • Top with the second leaf of lettuce and finally, the second slice of bread that has herb aioli spread on it, with the spread side facing inside.
  • Slice the sandwich diagonally in half and serve with your favorite sides!


Serving: 1sandwich | Calories: 320kcal | Carbohydrates: 41g | Protein: 23g | Fat: 9g | Saturated Fat: 2g | Cholesterol: 50mg | Sodium: 1310mg | Potassium: 491mg | Fiber: 7g | Sugar: 3g | Vitamin A: 5680IU | Vitamin C: 16mg | Calcium: 140mg | Iron: 3mg
Keyword Leftover Turkey, Thanksgiving, Zesty Garden Turkey Club Sandwich
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can a French bread slab be used in place of whole-grain bread for this sandwich? 

Yes, you can use a French bread slab in place of whole-grain bread for this sandwich if you would like. However, as the slab is larger, you will have to adjust the amount of ingredients accordingly. 

Can mustard be added to the herb aioli? 

Yes, if you like the flavor of mustard, you can add a dash of it to the herb aioli to make it extra zesty. 

What kind of cheese can be added to the zesty garden club sandwich? 

If you would like to add cheese to the sandwich, you can add some sharp cheddar, Monterey jack, or even Swiss cheese to this sandwich. 

Can bacon be added to this sandwich? 

Yes, you can surely add bacon to the sandwich if you like the flavor. 

Can lemon juice be added to the herb aioli in place of white wine vinegar? 

Yes, you can add lemon juice to the herb aioli, if you would like, in place of white wine vinegar. 


The best way to use up all the leftover turkey from Thanksgiving is to turn it into this Zesty Garden Club Sandwich! This sandwich is zesty for sure and also really hearty. Moreover, there are a lot of variations that can be made with this sandwich, all as per your personal flavor preferences. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating