Potbelly Menu With Prices [Updated April 2024]

Potbelly was a former antique shop that served toasted sandwiches to visitors. One day, a regular visitor who loved the complimentary sandwich bought the shop and turned it into a first-class dive for sandwiches. 

Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Since then, Potbelly has served the best sandwiches, soups, salads, fresh-baked cookies and milkshakes. Today, Potbelly is available at more than 400 locations and is known for its delectable range of menu items. 

Potbelly’s Latest Menu with Prices 

For your convenience, a drop-down button on every menu item is available. You have to click, and the table will magically expand. This lets you learn more about each menu item and whether they are vegan, keto-friendly, or gluten-free. 

Another cool thing you can try is clicking on different categories and jumping to other sections without hassle. Now, you can explore the menu prices at Potbelly very swiftly.

Featured Items | Sandwiches | Salads | Pick-Your-Pair | Chips + Sides | Cookies + Shakes | Drinks |

PriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Turkey Breast$8.39443NoNoNo No
Skinny Sandwich +Cup of Soup$14.29400NoyesNo, but you can customize it to make vegan by omitting certain ingredients.No
A Wreck$9.09538No, but you can customize it to make vegan by omitting certain ingredients.NoNoNo
Italian$9.09639No, but you can customize it to make vegan by omitting certain ingredients.NoNoNo

Sandwiches

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Turkey Breast$8.39443NoNoNo Yes
A Wreck$9.09538No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.NoNoNo
Italian$9.09639No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.NoNoNo
Chicken Club$9.69830NoNoNoNo
Pizza Melt$9.091100NoNo No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.Yes
Avo Turkey$9.69340No NoNoNo
Grilled Chicken$8.39126NoNoNo No
Mama’s Meatball$9.09870NoNoNoNo
Smoked Ham$8.39554NoNo NoNo
Mediterranean$9.69470No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.No
Veggie Melt$8.49450No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.YesNoNo
Roast Beef$8.39513NoNoNoNo
BLTA$9.39730No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.No, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.NoNo
Chicken Salad$8.39742NoNo, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.No No
Tuna Salad$8.39423NoNoNo No
Steakhouse Beef$9.69790NoNo, but it can be customized by omitting certain ingredients.NoNo

Salads

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Apple Walnut Salad$9.39850No, but you can make it vegan by customizing it with suitable ingredients. NoNoNo
Farm House Salad$9.39438No, but you can make it vegan by customizing it with suitable ingredients. No, but you can make it vegan by customizing it with suitable ingredients. No Yes
Power House Salad$9.39560No, but you can make it vegan by customizing it with suitable ingredients. No, but you can make it vegan by customizing it with suitable ingredients. No, but you can make it vegan by customizing it with suitable ingredients. No
Chicken Salad Salad$9.39742No, but you can make it vegan by customizing it with suitable ingredients. NoYesNo

Pick-Your-Pair

Item NamePriceCaloriesVegan VegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Skinny Sandwich +Cup of Soup$14.29400NoYesNo, but it can be made gluten-free by customizing it with suitable ingredients.No
Half Salad + Cup of Soup$14.5990YesYesNo Yes
Skinny Sandwich + Half Salad$16.49357NoYesNo No

Chips + Sides

Item NamePriceCaloriesVegan VegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Zapp’s Mesquite Bar-B-Que Chips$2.59220YesYesYesNo
Zapp’s Salt & Vinegar Chips$2.59220YesYesYesNo
Zapp’s Hotter ‘N Hot Jalapeño Chips$2.59150YesYesYes No
Baked Lay’s$2.59200YesYesYesNo
Zapp’s Regular Chips$2.59220YesYesYesNo
Zapp’s VooDoo Regular Chips$2.59220YesYesYesNo
Potbelly Whole Pickle$1.6925YesYesYesYes
Chips + Drinks$5.49460YesYesYesNo
Chips + Shake$5.49273NoYesYes No
Utz Cheese Curls$2.492000NoYesYes No
Zapp’s VooDoo Heat Chips$2.59220YesYesYesNo
Hot Peppers Jar$9.960YesYesYesYes

Cookies + Shakes

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie$2.99420NoNoNoNo
OREO® Cookie Shake$7.19770NoNo NoNo
Bag of Mini Cookies$6.2996NoNoNoNo
Sugar Cookie$2.99500NoNoNo No
Chocolate Shake$6.79770NoNoNoNo
Chocolate Brownie Cookie$2.99420NoNoNo No
Strawberry Shake$6.79641NoYesNoNo
Dream Bar$3.29434NoNoNoNo
Vanilla Shake$6.79587NoYesNoNo
Cold Brew Shake$7.19680NoYesNoNo
6-Pack Cookie Box$16.892000NoNoNo No

Drinks

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Diet Coke$4.290YesYesYesNo
Coke$4.29240YesYesYesNo
Powerade Mountain Berry Blast$4.29100YesYesYesNo
Coke Zero Sugar$4.292000YesYesYesNo
Sprite$4.29240YesYesYesNo
Cherry Coke$4.29260YesYesYesNo
Crush$3.89170YesYesNoNo
San Pellegrino$4.490YesYesYesYes
IBC Root Beer$4.49160YesYesYesYes
IBC Cream Soda$4.49180YesYesYesYes
Arizona Tea$4.19225YesYesYesYes
Vitamin Water Squeezed Lemonade$4.590YesYesYesYes
Nantucket Nectars Lemonade$4.59110YesYesNoYes
Bottled Water$2.990YesYesYesYes

Popular Items On The Potbelly’s Latest Menu 

Potbelly Deals

Potbelly is definitely a paradise for sandwich lovers. However, there are some menu options that are a must-try. You can visit the place during operating hours and feast on these delicious items.  

Let us look at the best items served at Potbelly so you can try them on your next visit. 

1. Wreck

A Wreck at Potbelly is one of their original creations, which has become quite popular among customers. It is like an ocean of meaty flavors, with Black Angus roast beef, old-world salami, oven-roasted turkey breast, and hickory smoked ham. Like a dream come true for all meat lovers.  

Looking at the wreck, you may feel the meat needs increased. However, the story does not end here; take a bite and get a burst of savory and hearty notes. It may seem like a lot is going on, but the different meats really complement each other, hitting the right spot

2. Turkey Breast

As people are choosing turkey as one of their protein options, Potbelly turkey breast has gained popularity. Why does Potbelly Turkey breast a catch? The slow-roasted turkey between well-toasted breads with two Swiss cheeses brings out satiating flavors. 

The best thing about this sub is that you can feel the crunch along the tender turkey. Add some hot peppers to level up the game and make things a little hot. 

3. Oatmeal Chocolate Chip

When you look at the Potbelly oatmeal chocolate chip cookie, it may seem simple. However, the flavors are too good and quite different from regular chocolate chip cookies. Now, what sets them apart is the generous amount of oatmeal. The more oatmeal, the better the sturdy texture of the cookie. 

When you hold these cookies, you will find how soft yet crumbly (perfect in the cookie world) they are. Take a bite, and sugar will rush to your brain, making you smile wide. 

5. Italian Sandwich

Only some sandwich places have this good Italian sub like the one at Potbelly. This simple and clean sandwich has a burst of Italian notes. It has really well-toasted bread that holds pepperoni, ham, and salami. On top of these meats, you can get some lettuce, onions, and extra pickles. 

The secret flavor in this sub is, for sure, the Italian dressing, along with the sauce made with mayo and mustard. While you take a bite, you will love the combination of meat with the sauce dripping down, so use some napkins. This sandwich has everything—perfect moistness, decent chewiness, and great crunch. 

6. Mediterranean Sandwich

Drop everything now because Potbelly has the best Mediterranean sandwich, which makes a vegan option (if you skip chicken and feta). The real reason behind its popularity is the zesty hummus that Potbelly has been using as a sandwich spread. 

Before you frown upon that, adding humus may be a great idea. The hot hummus, combined with artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, cucumbers, and grilled chicken (if you want any), brings out the Mediterranean flavor. The addition of feta and mayo tops the flavors, making it a unique and popular option. 

7. Broccoli Cheddar Soup

Apart from their sandwich, Potbelly is known for its broccoli cheddar soup. It is one of the most popular side options as it has a perfect balance of flavor. With a little bit of earthiness and a hint of bitterness, it gives a very contrasting yet delicate note. 

This is not even the best part because this soup has the perfect amount of cheese, unlike other cheese-based soups (that taste like only cheese and nothing else). So, if you want to enjoy a well-seasoned, thick, American-style soup with tender broccoli and carrots, this one is perfect. 

8. Chicken Pot Pie

Potbelly chicken pot pie has to be the most comforting menu item. A generous amount of crispy yet tender chicken chunks topped with a thick and creamy broth is what anyone would love on a chili day. 

Before the flavors, the aroma of this pot pie will hit you, making you crave more. That is why this pot pie is said to be a bowl full of warmth, making it one of the popular menu options at Potbelly. Take a slurp, and you will love the warm broth with hearty and savory chicken pieces.

9. Veggie Melt

Veggie melt from Potbelly may not be everyone’s first choice, but it is heaven for vegetarians. The reason behind it is simple: it has a significant amount of freshly sliced avocado paired with provolone and mushrooms. 

That is not all; it also has Swiss and cheddar cheese, giving it a nice gooey texture. The best part is that even though it is super soft and moist, you will enjoy a decent crunch as the bread is well-toasted. All this coming together in a single bite makes this one of the satiating and popular options for vegetarians.  

What People Are Asking About Potbelly’s Menu?

Potbelly Outlet

You may still have some questions about Potbelly. Don’t worry; I have tried answering everything below that you may want to know about Potbelly before you visit. 

What Are The Operating Hours Of Potbelly?

Potbelly’s operating hours are between 9 a.m. and 10 p.m., but the timings may differ from location to location. 

Does Potbelly Use Real Meat?

Yes, Potbelly uses the finest quality white breast that is free from preservatives, chemicals, and artificial ingredients and minimally processed. The meat is sourced from local suppliers that follow all USDA regulations. 

What Payment Modes Does Potbelly Accept?

Potbelly accepts almost every payment method, including debit cards, credit cards, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. You can use any Mastercard to purchase Potbelly.  

Can We Order Potbelly Online?

Yes, you can easily order any menu item from Potbelly online. You can visit their official website or check out other food delivery platforms like Doordash, Seamless, and Grubhub to order. 

Is Potbelly Healthy?

Many items at Potbelly have high carbs and sodium content. However, adding lots of veggies can make the menu items healthy. You can also go for the soups and salads as they are more nutritious than sandwiches served at Potbelly. 

Does Potbelly Have a Secret Menu?

Yes, Potbelly has a secret menu under the name ‘Underground menu’ which is verified by the restaurant. You simply have to download the Potbelly app and get access to the Potbelly Underground menu.  

What Bread Does Potbelly Use?

Potbelly uses multigrain bread for all its sandwiches, which makes the menu items a great healthy option. 

What Is The 8-minute Rule At Potbelly?

The 8-minute rule at Potbelly means you must place your order and receive your meal in 8 minutes or less. 

Does Potbelly Have Catering Services?

Yes, Potbelly also provides catering services. Depending on your requirements, you can visit the website to get a quote. 

Can We Get Gift Cards At Potbelly?

Potbelly provides gift cards you can purchase online or at any outlet. 

Current Deals Running At Potbelly 

Potbelly Popular Menu Items

Eating at Potbelly is not only about flavors; you can easily save a few bucks on your purchase. These offers may differ depending on the location of the outlet. Let us have a look at current deals that you need to know before your visit:

1. Free Sandwich

At Potbelly, you are rewarded for every purchase. Simply join the Potbelly perks, and with every purchase, you earn points that can be redeemed for free menu items. 

Moreover, you also get a free sandwich after your first purchase of $5 or more when you join.

2. Buy One, Get One

If you order one BIG or Original Sandwich at Potbelly, you also get an Original Sandwich for free. You need to use the promo code ‘BOGO,’ and you can get a free sandwich. 

You can even use this code when placing your order online through the Potbelly website or other delivery platforms. 

3. Free Cookie

If you love Potbelly’s cookies, this deal is definitely for you. However, it is not an official deal, but You get a free cookie with the purchase of every individual basic belly box lunch (must order 10) at Potbelly Sandwich Shop. 

To get your free cookie, you simply need to use the code ‘Free Cookie’ on Potbelly’s official website. 

How We’ve Verified This Data

At the FoodXP, our team members verify all the information through the restaurant’s official website. To avoid discrepancies, the team also cross-checks the details through other leading delivery platforms. 

You can always contact your nearest outlet and check for the details, as information may vary depending on the location. To learn more about our verification process, you can head to our website and view the menu price policy

Other Restaurants’ Menus That We’ve Covered

We have covered the menus of similar fast-food chains, like Potbelly. If you love delicious sandwiches, try the O’Brien’s Irish Sandwich Cafe menu. I have also heard a lot about ​​Lee’s Sandwiches, and you need to check out their menu.

Similar to these outlets, Bobby’s Burger Palace is a great place to have burgers, and it has the best burger menu. If you like Potbelly cookies, you must try Ben’s Cookies Menu and enjoy the freshly baked sweet delights. 

Conclusion 

As we are at the end, you know what to order the next time you are at Potbelly. Potbelly also has an underground menu, which is fun to explore again. This information was helpful. Try the oatmeal cookies at Potbelly and thank me later. Until then, eat sandwiches. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *