Creamy Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Copycat Recipe

The hot and spicy Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce is an excellent addition to your kitchen to make your daily meal enjoyable. Moreover, it is one of the most convenient options for pairing your go-to food. 

Thick pizza sauce

The astonishing sauce goes well with your pasta recipe, fries, and burgers. The flavors of the dishes come out more beautifully when paired with this Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce. 

Now, without further ado, let’s move on to additional details like ingredients, steps, and nutritional information. You will also find some tips and tricks to help you attain better flavors. 

Is This The Exact Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Recipe?

Yes, this is the exact recipe for Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce. Our chef made it with total effort, which was the best. His efforts bring out perfect flavors and textures in the sauce. 

However, there’s a twist: unlike the restaurant, our chef doesn’t use additives and preservatives, which makes a better version. 

How Is Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Different From Regular Pizza Sauce?

Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce is similar to regular pizza sauce because some common ingredients are used, like garlic powder, tomato sauce, fried oregano, salt, and pepper. 

However, the only difference is regular pizza sauce uses Italian seasoning while Pizza Hut Pizza. This sauce uses dried basil leaves, thyme, and whole bay leaf.

Why You’ll Love This Pizza Sauce Recipe?

There are various reasons to love this amazing Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce. Let’s take a look below to learn more:

  • Best For More Culinary Dishes Other Than Pizzas – Creamy Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce can also be paired with more culinary dishes other than pizzas. The sauce is perfect for bringing different flavors, from fries to chicken wings. 
  • Customization – Homemade sauce allows you to customize it per your taste preferences. You can also customize it according to your dietary needs. Feel free to add your twist.
  • Healthy – Making a homemade version of the sauce is better than purchasing from the store. Homemade sauces are always more nutritious than store-bought ones.
  • Cost Effective – I prefer making it home rather than purchasing and paying vast amounts of money at the restaurant. It’ll get ready at the most affordable price, along with a better taste.

Is This Pizza Sauce Vegan And Gluten-Free?

You won’t believe it, but this pizza sauce is both gluten- and vegan-free, as it contains no gluten-containing ingredients.

Now, you can enjoy this fantastic pizza sauce, whether on diet restrictions or not. 

Equipment Required For Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce

  • Saucepan – For boiling the tomatoes, use a saucepan. 
  • Ladle – You will need a spoon to mix the ingredients. 
  • Empty Container – Store the sauce in an empty container.

Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Ingredients

  • Tomato Sauce – Tomato sauce adds a hearty taste to the pizza sauce. It adds a sweetness to it.
  • Sugar – Sugar will neutralize the spiciness in the sauce. 
  • Water- Water gives the sauce the desired consistency.
  • Dried Oregano – Add dried oregano to this pizza sauce for refreshing, spicy, and savory flavors. 
  • Dried Basil Leaves – Dried basil leaves add a minty flavor to the sauce. 
  • Dried Thyme – Dried thyme brings a robust herbal flavor to this pizza sauce. 
  • Garlic Powder – Enhance the restaurant-style Pizza Sauce with a tinge of garlic powder. It will bring out the aromatic and mild flavors of the sauce. 
  • Salt – Add salt according to the taste preferences. 
  • Black Pepper – Sprinkle black pepper in the sauce for a spicy kick. 
  • Whole Bay Leaf – Add whole bay leaf to the sauce for a sharp, tangy, and bitter taste.
  • Lemon Juice – Add a teaspoon of lemon juice to this sauce for a hint of sourness. It also helps in increasing the shelf life of the sauce. 

 Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Ingredients Substitutions

  • Lime – For the sauce with a hint of tartness and sweetness, use lime juice instead of lemon juice.
  • Garlic Flakes – If you don’t have garlic powder, use garlic flakes instead. It is the closest replacement for garlic powder.
  • Kosher Salt – The best salt substitute is kosher salt, which has more extensive and coarser grains, positively affecting flavor and texture. 
  • Parsley – Replacing dried oregano with parsley is a beneficial choice based on the flavor profile. Parsley brings out a fresh, slightly peppery flavor in the dish. 
  • Fresh Basil – If you don’t have dried basil leaves, replace them with fresh ones. It is primarily available in every store.
  • Rosemary – Substitute dried thyme with rosemary for a different flavor profile. It offers a pine-like flavor with a hint of citrus. Also, if you don’t have both, use a 1:3 substitute of fresh thyme. 

Does Pizza Hut Use Fresh Tomatoes To Make Their Pizza Sauce?

No, Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce is not made with fresh tomatoes but uses vine-ripened canned tomatoes. Pizza Hut does not use fresh tomatoes but emphasizes that its sauce is made with high-quality ingredients. 

Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Preparation And Cooking Time

Preparation TimeCooking Time Total Time
5 Minutes 25 Minutes 30 Minutes

Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Recipe Steps

  • Take a pan and pour tomato sauce in it.
  • Add garlic powder to the pan according to the servings. 
  • Now, add sugar to the mix. 
  • Add dried oregano to the pan. 
  • Add dried thyme to the pan. 
  • Now, add dried Basil leaves to the pan. 
  • Pour water into the pan.
  • Season the mix with pepper
  • After the pepper, season the sauce with salt.
  • Add a whole bay leaf to the pan. 
  • Pour corn syrup into the pan. 
  • Now, let the sauce cook for a few minutes.
  • Your hot and spicy pizza sauce is ready to serve. 

Tips To Make This Pizza Sauce Better

How about giving different flavor profiles to your pizza sauce? Below are some tips that will help you attain some different flavors:

  • Herbs And Spices – You can get better flavors and taste of the sauce by using herbs and spices other than Basil and thyme. Consider using fennel seeds for a subtle earthiness or onion to add a hint of sourness. 
  • Give A Spicy Kick – Add smoked paprika or red chili flakes to the sauce. So, if you enjoy spiciness in your food, adding the mentioned elements will help enhance the sauce’s flavors.
  • Sweetness And Acidity – For a hint of brightness, add red wine vinegar or balsamic vinegar, while a touch of brown sugar or honey can balance the flavors.

How Will This Pizza Sauce Look & Taste Like?

Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce is a beautiful red, which looks appealing and inviting. Along with red, there is also a hint of green, which comes from added herbs. The combination of red and green makes it look even more enjoyable. 

Besides this, the sauce is packed with excellent sweet, tangy, and spicy flavors. Using high-quality tomatoes brings a better taste to the sauce.

Why Is Your Pizza Sauce Watery & Thin? 

Your pizza sauce can end up with a watery consistency due to the following reasons:

  • Excessive Lemon Juice – Excess of lemon juice can make your sauce watery and thin. So, to avoid this mistake, ensure that lemon juice is used as per the requirements. 
  • Wrong Cooking Time – Cook the pizza sauce for at least 30 minutes or up to one hour. It may give you watery results if not cooked for the mentioned time. So, make sure to cook the sauce for 
  • Too Much Tomato Sauce – Adding too much tomato sauce can also be problematic, making your sauce thin. So make sure to use tomato sauce as per the desired consistency. 

Why Does Your Sauce Taste Bland?

If your sauce tastes bland, you need to know the reason. Go through the guide mentioned below to see why this is happening.

  • Less Salt & Pepper – Salt and pepper will be crucial to this recipe. Ensure that you add the right amount of salt and black pepper so that the taste is not affected. 
  • Not Enough Herbs And Spices – Herbs and spices add a good amount of flavor to the sauce. Therefore, you must be careful when adding the proper amount of herbs and spices. 
  • Use Good-quality Tomatoes – Ensure you use good-quality tomatoes for the best results. Good quality tomatoes will surely make your sauce taste better.

Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Nutritional Values

Pizza sauce is typically made with tomato sauce, including some spices, making it a healthy option. Now, let’s move on to the detailed calorific values of this Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce. 

Calories 45 kcal
Dietary Fiber 2 g
Sodium 290 mg
Sugar 6 g
Protein 1 g
Carbohydrates 9 g

Can You Make This Pizza Sauce Ahead Of Time?

Make it ahead of time, and you will see the magic. It’ll serve you a lot of benefits which will make you crazy. Now let’s go through them one by one:

  • Enhanced Flavors – Making this sauce ahead of time brings beautiful flavors. The resting time will let the flavors absorb correctly, which gives you more delicious results. 
  • Best For Instant Use – Let’s say some special guests are arriving, and they feel like eating pizza, so you order it for them. But think how convenient it’ll be if you have this pizza sauce available already. You can serve pizza with this fantastic pizza sauce. 

How Can You Store This Recipe?

Storing can make things easier for you. So, there is no need to waste your leftovers. Instead, you can use any of the ways mentioned below:

  • Refrigerating – You can refrigerate this pizza sauce quickly for up to six to seven days without losing its flavors and textures. However, you must ensure it is correctly sealed in an airtight container or a glass jar. This will save your sauce from absorbing the odors from the other items kept in the fridge. 
  • Freezer – You can store this Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce in a freezer. You’ll be amazed it can stay up to a week when stored in a freezer. But you have to take care of one thing: you will need to reheat the sauce before serving for the best flavors. 
  • Room Temperature – Keeping this pizza sauce at room temperature for over two hours is unsafe. Bacteria can start growing, ruining the sauce’s taste and flavor. Ensure to transfer it to the fridge or freezer after two hours. 

Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce Printable Version

Glazy pizza sauce

Pizza Hut Sauce Recipe

Pizza Hut pizza sauce adds extra flavors to the pizza. Moreover, this copycat pizza sauce can be prepared with a handful of herbs and spices. Put your apron on and get started preparing the sauce.
4.89 from 9 votes
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 25 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes
Course copycat
Cuisine American
Servings 10
Calories 45 kcal


  • Saucepan
  • Ladle
  • Empty Container


  • 1 Cup Tomato Sauce
  • 1 Teaspoon Sugar
  • ¼ Cup Water
  • ¼ Teaspoon Dried Oregano
  • ¼ Teaspoon Dried Basil Leaves
  • ¼ Teaspoon Dried Thyme
  • ¼ Teaspoon Garlic Powder
  • ¼ Teaspoon Salt
  • Teaspoon Black Pepper
  • 1 Whole Bay Leaf
  • ½ Teaspoon Lemon Juice


  • Take a pan and pour tomato sauce in it.
  • Add garlic powder to the pan according to the servings.
  • Now, add sugar to the mix.
  • Add dried oregano to the pan.
  • Add dried thyme to the pan.
  • Now, add dried Basil leaves to the pan.
  • Pour water into the pan.
  • Season the mix with pepper
  • After the pepper, season the sauce with salt.
  • Add a whole bay leaf to the pan.
  • Pour corn syrup into the pan.
  • Now, let the sauce cook for a few minutes.
  • Your hot and spicy pizza sauce is ready to serve.




Calories: 45kcal | Carbohydrates: 9g | Protein: 1g | Sodium: 290mg | Fiber: 2g | Sugar: 6g
Keyword Pizza Hut, Pizza Hut Pizza sauce, Pizza Sauce, Tomato Pizza Sauce
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What Kind Of Pizza Sauces Does Pizza Hut Have?

Pizza Hut offers an assortment of sauces including tomato pizza sauce, marinara, Parmesan, and honey sriracha, 

What Is Pizza Sauce Made From?

Just with a few ingredients, pizza sauce can be prepared at home. You need canned tomatoes, garlic, balsamic vinegar, olive oil, black pepper, salt, thyme leaves, oregano, Italian seasoning, and crushed red chili flakes.

Can We Use Marinara Sauce For Pizza?

Yes, you can use marinara sauce while preparing pizza. The marinara sauce has a blend of tomatoes and onions. 

Is Pizza Hut Marinara Sauce The Same As Pizza Sauce?

Marinara sauce and pizza sauce are different. There is a blend of tomatoes and onions in marinara and pizza sauce is only prepared by using tomatoes.


Let’s wrap up here, and we will see you in the following upcoming recipe. Till then, try out this fantastic Pizza Hut Pizza Sauce recipe at home and enjoy the same taste and flavors as Pizza Hut. 

If you liked this pizza sauce recipe, you should also check out further restaurant-style recipes. How To Make Pizza Hut Garlic Sauce At Home, Appetizing Pizza Hut Buffalo Wings Copycat Recipe, How To Make Pizza Hut Taco Pizza At Home, How To Make Pizza Hut Pan Pizza At Home, How To Make Pizza Hut Chicken Alfredo Pasta At Home, How To Make Pizza Hut Thin Crust Pizza At Home

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating