McDonald’s Holiday Pie Review | Best Holiday Menu Item?

Every Christmas, McDonald’s creates a special menu for its customers. The holiday pie is one of their most popular offerings. But is the McDonald’s holiday pie the best holiday menu item? Let’s find out in this McDonald’s holiday pie review! 

McDonald’s holiday pie truly makes for a delicious sweet treat. Creamy and smooth, McDonald’s holiday pie features a flaky, buttery crust with vanilla custard filling. It’s typically priced at $1.19. 

However, getting your hands on a holiday pie is sometimes easier said than done. Firstly, the holiday pie is available only during the holiday season, like Christmas. Secondly, with its massive popularity, stores go out of stock quickly during the holiday operating hours.

If you are contemplating spending those bucks on the McDonald’s holiday pie, review the article to find customer reviews. 

What’s In A McDonald’s Holiday Pie?

McDonald's Holiday Pie

I’m sure you are excited to enjoy the holiday pie as the season is nearing. But before you get your hands on it, let’s look at what it’s made of.

McDonald’s Holiday Pie Ingredients:

  1. Milk
  2. Enriched Flour (bleached Wheat Flour) 
  3. Palm Oil
  4. Sugar
  5. Water
  6. Modified Food Starch, Topping (sugar, Corn Starch, Hydrogenated Cottonseed Oil, Confectioner’s Glaze)
  7. Salt
  8. Cream Of Tartar
  9. Natural And Artificial Flavors

How Does McDonald’s Holiday Pie Taste? 

McDonald's Holiday Pie

McDonald’s holiday pie is a delicious vanilla-flavored sweet treat with a mild but flavorful sweetness that appeals to adults and children alike. This classic dessert comes glazed with sugar and red and green confetti crystals—perfect for spreading holiday cheer! 

The holiday pie features a buttery, flaky crust filled with creamy vanilla custard to taste like Christmas. The combination of creamy custard-like filling and crunchy cookie crust makes for a divine mouthfeel you will not get enough of. 

Additionally, many people appreciate how easy it is to enjoy. Thus, McDonald’s holiday pie has become a favorite among customers. If you happen upon one during your holiday, try it—you won’t regret it!

What Do People Say About McDonald’s Holiday Pie?

McDonald's Holiday Pie

McDonald’s holiday pie has been winning hearts since it was first introduced. People wait for the holiday season to arrive to enjoy them. So, let’s take a look at what people have to say about them.

Upon its arrival, a Twitter user wrote – “Holiday pie is Back @McDonalds. I waited a whole year for this.”

While reviewing the pie, a YouTube channel named The Endorsement said – “I’m not a fan of vanilla custard, but this pie is good. It looks like a sugar cookie with its sugar coating and sprinkles. 

Another YouTube reviewer said – “It smells buttery. The custard is creamy and warm. The crust tastes like a cookie crust. Sometimes custard can be weird, but this one is pretty good.”

A third one said: “It tastes like a vanilla cupcake. It tastes good. I enjoy it!”

Praising the pies further, a Reddit user wrote – “I’m addicted to these things…if there aren’t drugs in these, I would be surprised. I could also just be depressed.” Another one wrote, “This and the pumpkin cream pies are so freaking delicious. I like them chilled in the fridge first before I eat them.” A third one wrote – “My grandma loved these.”

What’s My Review On McDonald’s Holiday Pie?

McDonald's Holiday Pie

Now that we’ve reached the end of the article let me give you my opinion on the pie. The holiday pies at McDonald’s are worth the hype. I would give them five stars. They are incredibly delectable and well worth the wait.

While the vanilla flavors convey the traditional Christmas sensation, the pie’s creamy and crispy texture is delicious. You won’t be able to stop after one bite.

So, if you’re debating whether to try them, go for it. They are little packages of warmth that will make you long for your grandmother’s baking.

Is McDonald’s Holiday Pie Healthy?

McDonald's Holiday Pie

Yes, McDonald’s holiday pie is healthy to eat. It’s not high in calories, fat, or carbohydrates. However, eating them in moderation is always advisable to take care of your health.

To better understand the nutritional profile, look at McDonald’s Holiday Pie calories.  

Calories260 cal
Carbohydrates32 g
Protein3 g
Fat12 g
Saturated Fat6 g
Cholesterol5 mg
Sodium150 mg
Potassium125 mg
Fiber4 g
Sugar12 g

Can You Make A Better Version Of McDonald’s Holiday Pie At Home?

McDonald's Holiday Pie

Yes, you can make McDonald’s holiday pie at home. You can easily make them healthy by opting for good-quality ingredients.

For example, you make a preservative-free homemade custard filling and crust. So, look at the McDonald’s holiday pie recipe to enjoy it throughout the year.


McDonald’s is not just a fast-food chain; its food has also become an integral part of the holiday season. It always comes up with exciting and innovative ideas to delight its customers, and its holiday offerings are no exception. 

Be it Halloween or Christmas, you can pick up delectable sweet treats for your friends and family. However, the McDonald’s holiday pies are only available for a limited time. Therefore, you should check with your nearest location to ensure they have it before you head out. 

Like these pies, McDonald’s offers other delightful treats to make the festive season more special. Before making a purchase, why don’t you look at what people say about McDonald’s Shamrock Shake, McDonald’s Egg Nog Shake, and McDonald’s Apple Pie?

Moreover, you can also enjoy McDonald’s parfait at home, which tastes identical to the one available at the store.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is McDonald’s Holiday Pie available all year round?

No McDonald’s Holiday Pie are not available all year round.

What does McDonald’s Holiday Pie taste like?

McDonald’s Holiday Pie has a vanilla-flavored custard filling. Therefore, they taste like sugar cookies.

Can we make McDonald’s Holiday Pie at home?

Yes, you can make McDonald’s Holiday Pie at home.

Is McDonald’s Holiday Pie expensive?

No, McDonald’s Holiday Pie is not an expensive treat.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *