Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu

If you love sandwiches more than anything else, then you can get the most out of every bite at Jersey Mike’s. But did you know Jersey Mike’s has a sumptuous secret menu that can be ordered for a change?

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu

You might be a Jersey Mike’s veteran and would know their official menu by heart. But if you didn’t know about your favorite restaurant’s secret menu, then you have landed at the right place.

At Jersey Mike’s, you can also relish some exciting off-the-menu sandwiches, salads, and wraps that taste equally delectable as their regular items for a refreshing change.

Jersey Mike’s opened their doors in 1956. While many sub-shops have a larger popularity than Jersey Mike’s, this place is the best when it comes to meat sandwiches. 

Jersey Mike’s specializes in serving sandwiches that are generously loaded with a variety of meat on a bed of lettuce, tomatoes, onions, cheese, and sauces. 

It’s safe to say they have the attention for all the right reasons! This article will teach you about Jersey Mike’s secret menu items. Check them out, and I suggest you try as many as possible because you will surely be surprised.

Jersey Mike’s Secret Menu

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu

Jersey Mike’s secret menu offers a delicious variety of sandwiches, salads, and wraps to make your day better. Check them out!

1. R & R Special

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu

If you are a big fan of deli meat, then the R & R special sandwich from Jersey Mike’s secret menu should definitely be on your list. A standard deli Reuben features rye bread sandwiching a lineup of corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing. But the R & R Special takes it to the next level.

To make this sandwich, Jersey Mike’s uses its freshly baked white or wheat sub and stuffs it with corned beef and pastrami. It is lined up with a hearty helping of melted Swiss, coleslaw instead of sauerkraut, and Russian dressing. 

The creamy coleslaw, the soft sub, and the deli meat add a beautiful play of textures and, of course, flavors to this sandwich.

2. Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo

Jersey Mike's Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo

This sandwich is an exciting option on Jersey Mike’s secret menu that brings together the best of two worlds. This sub is a cross of the Big Kahuna Cheesesteak and the Chipotle Cheesesteak.

What do we get here? A delicious combination of a classic cheesesteak with Southwestern chilies and sauces.

The Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo features a sizzling steak dressed up with grilled onion, bell peppers, grilled jalapenos, and mushrooms. Then comes a layer of gooey melted American cheese and chipotle mayo for a spicy twist on a Philadelphia classic. Need I say more?

3. The BLT

jersey mike's The BLT

Now, you would expect any sandwich-specializing restaurant to have the basic BLT on its menu. However, Jersey Mike’s view on this sandwich differs. This restaurant chain doesn’t offer BLT in its official menu. 

However, you can place an order for it and be sure of having the freshest ingredients to have a BLT at Jersey Mike’s. Moreover, you could even customize your BLT by adding some jalapenos for a spicy kick and fresh Swiss cheese to complement the salty bacon.

You can also ask your server to add onions, pepperoncini, provolone, or anything else of your choice. The possibilities are endless!

4. The Meateor

The Meateor

The Meateor is a great invention by a loyal Jersey Mike’s customer who made this sandwich popular on social media. This bad boy boasts 8 varieties of meat: bacon, salami, Prosciutto, Turkey, roast beet, ham, capicola, and pepperoni. 

Phew! That was a long list! And now, add your choice of fresh vegetables, sauces, and pickles to that list!

5. The Chick-Fila-Roni

Jersey Mike's The Chick-Fila-Roni

The Chick-Fila-Roni is a pure delight. This sub features breaded chicken topped with grilled onions and bell peppers with melted provolone cheese. You also get a layer of fresh pepperoni and a drizzle of delicious chipotle mayo to finish it all off.

6. Sub-In-A-Tub


Sub-in-a-tub from Jersey Mike’s is a great choice for those wanting to cut on those extra carbs. At Jersey Mike’s, you can enjoy the goodness of a sub without guilt by asking your server to place all the contents in a tub – sans bread. 

So, they will prepare a sandwich of your choice with all the fillings in a sub-size container. This Jersey Mike’s secret menu item is not just great for cutting out on carbs but also is a gluten-free option. 

7. Lumberjack Salad

Lumberjack Salad

Following the same concept of Sub-in-a-tub, the lumberjack salad is Jersey Mike’s Club Supreme sub in a bowl. This mouthwatering bowl features a hefty portion of meats layered with a mix of fresh vegetables. 

You can enjoy sumptuous flavors of Applewood smoked bacon, roast beef, and turkey over a bed of lettuce and tomatoes. This goodness comes with a drizzle of spicy mustard sauce. 

If you wish to make it more salad-like, you can add more vegetables like onions, peppers, cucumbers, olives, and an oil and vinegar drizzle.

8. Greek Grilled Chicken Salad

jersey mike  Greek Grilled Chicken Salad

Love a chicken Caesar wrap but want to have it as a salad? Order the Greek grilled chicken salad! All you have to say is, “one chicken Caesar wrap in a tub, please, with no Caesar dressing.”

9. Surf ‘n’ Turf

jersey mike Surf 'n' Turf

Are you on the lookout for a fish sandwich? Order the surf ‘n’ turf from Jersey Mike’s secret menu. This sub includes roast beef, tuna, and provolone, along with the veggies of your choice. This sandwich has garnered huge popularity among Jersey Mike’s customers.

10. The Martian

The Martian

You can find the Martian on Jersey Mike’s official menu on and off. However, on the days when they take it off, you can still order this delicacy.

The Martian is an Italian-style sandwich that features cappacuolo, salami, provolone, and pepperoni. 

When you call out for The Martian, your server will know what to do. However, if you are engaging with a new server, you can ask for a super-sub and replace pepperoni for prosciutto and salami for ham. 

To take this sandwich to a new level, add tomatoes, lettuce, hot peppers, oil, and vinegar.

11. Meatball Supreme Pizza Sub

jersey mike Meatball Supreme Pizza Sub

Can’t you do without meatballs? Well then, enjoy them in a sub from Jersey Mike’s. 

The meatball supreme pizza sub features meatballs paired with grilled onion, pepper, and mushrooms. Then comes a generous drizzle of the classic red sauce and melted provolone cheese. This sub is a pure delight!

12. Pepperoni Pizza Sub

Pepperoni Pizza Sub

If you land at Jersey Mike’s and your kids suddenly demand a pepperoni pizza, you can go anywhere. That’s because Jersey Mike’s genius chefs have a solution for this – pepperoni pizza sub!

So, you place an order by telling the server to add the classic red sauce on the bottom slice of the bread and top it with provolone cheese and pepperoni. Ask them to heat it, and your pizza sub is ready! 

13. Sweet Pepper Wrap

jersey mike's Sweet Pepper Wrap

Moving on from sandwiches and salads, Jersey Mike’s secret menu also has a delicious wrap waiting for you. And this one is especially for the vegetarian folks or in case you plan to swap meat for veggies for the day.

The sweet pepper wrap is made with a tomato-basil-flavored tortilla. The tortilla encases within it white onion, cherry pepper relish, tomato, grilled sweet bell peppers, lettuce, white American cheese, and spicy chipotle mayo. 

To add umami flavors, you can ask your server to add grilled mushrooms to this wrap. The perfect combination of sweet, spicy flavors and crunchy fillings might make this wrap your regular order. 

Similar Restaurants That Offer A Secret Menu

  1. Chipotle – Chipotle is another place that serves lip smacking Mexican food and their secret menu is really vast!
  2. Five Guys – You have probably never heard of Five Guys secret menu. If you haven’t, then you need to check it out! 
  3. Dairy Queen – Dairy Queen has the most decadent selection of desserts, ice creams and beverages, even on their secret menu!
  4. Wendy’s – Wendy’s, although a fast food chain, has some of the most gourmet burgers on their secret menu. 
  5. Panda Express – Panda Express has a lot to offer on its secret menu and is something that the health-conscious should surely have a look at! 
  6. Whataburger – Burgers so delicious, even on their secret menu, that they make you say, “What-a-burger!”. 
  7. Subway – Subway has some delicious sandwich variations and a lot more, all on their secret menu.
  8. Wawa – Wawa has some really amazing and over the top breakfast options, all on their secret menu! 
  9. Arby’s – Arby’s is one stop to enjoy every sort of fast food and the sheer variety on their secret menu just proves so. 
  10. Waffle House – As the name suggests, waffle house has some really great sweet and savory waffle options on their secret menu. 


Aren’t you happy to find so many delicious options from Jersey Mike’s secret menu? Try them all out, and thank me later! 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *