7 Best Substitutes For Fire Roasted Tomatoes

Fire Roasted Tomatoes

You must’ve heard about a classic fiery tomato mac and cheese recipe, and you might’ve thought to give it a try. But since you have a particular penchant for blowing things up while roasting (like Seamus Finnigan from the Harry Potter series), you are forced to seek a few substitutes for it.

Pondering about the best substitutes for fire-roasted tomatoes? Some of them are freshly diced tomatoes, canned tomatoes, sun-dried tomatoes, and tomato puree.

Fire-roasted tomatoes are freshly halved tomatoes seasoned with spices that are roasted or grilled. They have the remarkable potential of transforming an otherwise dull food or dish into a mouth-watering one.

Let us talk about fire roasted tomatoes and find some best substitutes for them so that your cooking adventures go unhampered.

What Are Fire Roasted Tomatoes?

Fire Roasted Tomatoes

You already must have understood what fire-roasted tomatoes are by the name. They are tomatoes roasted on fire. Not as simple as that, but with added spices and flavoring agents. It just makes them incredibly satisfying and delicious.

Fire-roasted tomatoes register an intense, rich sweet flavor of tomatoes which is perfectly blended with the smoky flavor of fire. Usually, roasted tomatoes are diced, mashed, or pureed based on the recipes.

Many wrongly assume fire-roasted tomatoes to be the same as stewed tomatoes. Stewed tomatoes are freshly chopped tomatoes that are cooked and canned. Fire-roasted tomatoes are roasted on fire. Here are a few stewed tomatoes substitutes for you.

There are easy ways to turn your diced or canned tomatoes into something as ravishing as fire-roasted tomatoes. Keep reading to find out!

Uses of Fire Roasted Tomatoes

Fire-roasted tomatoes are used to intensify the flavor of what you are cooking. Be it soups, salads, stir-fries, pizzas, pasta, sauces, or sandwiches. They are also great companions to chicken, pork, beef, or other veggies. 

Fire-roasted tomatoes simply rock on their own as a standalone dish also. They are used to enrich many recipes such as Latin scrambled eggs, zucchini beef rice skillet, buffalo chicken chili, pepper steak pasta, and Fajita chicken burgers.

Well, well. To put it simply, everything is beautiful with fire-roasted tomatoes. But no one wants it ugly when you are out of them, right? 

Let us talk about how to use ingredients that work best as substitutes for fire-roasted tomatoes.

7 Best Substitutes For Fire Roasted Tomatoes

So, it’s time for us to discuss the substitutes. The seven best substitutes for fire-roasted tomatoes are as follows:

1. Freshly Diced Tomatoes

Freshly Diced Tomatoes

Obviously and undoubtedly, your best possible substitute for fire-roasted tomatoes is a bunch of nicely sliced fresh tomatoes. You will easily get the sweet-sour flavor of tomatoes.

The only difference between the diced tomatoes and fire-roasted tomatoes will be in the texture and flavor. But that can be easily handled if you add a seasoning of your choice.

Often used seasonings include paprika, chili, soy sauce, garlic, pepper, basil, miso, etc. You can choose anyone among these along with fresh tomatoes and simply make the recipe yum.

2. Canned Tomatoes

Canned Tomatoes

If you are out of fresh tomatoes, you can easily go with a bottle of canned tomatoes to replace fire-roasted tomatoes. The taste and flavor of canned tomatoes vary with respect to the brands. But most of them have a sweet taste with an acidic tweak.

Canned tomatoes are not a healthy alternative just because they are not fresh. Duh. Nevertheless, the nutrients are present, and thus they can save you if you are in a tight spot.

3. Sun-dried Tomatoes

Sun-dried Tomatoes

As the name suggests, sun-dried tomatoes are tomatoes that have been dried under the sun. It is not as easy as you visualize, though. Before drying, these tomatoes are marinated in either salt or sulfur dioxide. This gives them a wrinkled appearance.

They are one of the best alternatives for fire-roasted tomatoes, considering their sweet, savory flavor and crispy texture. They have a unique flavor and can be used to make pizzas, pasta, or other dishes that call for fire-roasted tomatoes, except in sauces.  

4. Tomato Puree

Tomato Puree

Tomato puree is prepared by grinding cooked tomatoes along with salt. It has a syrupy consistency with an intense essence of tomatoes and tartness. Its taste can be further enhanced by adding pepper or other seasoning agents.

When used as an alternative for fire-roasted tomatoes, the only downside would be its semi-solid texture. If needed, you can add a few chunks of tomatoes to the puree for a similar appeal as to that of fire-roasted tomatoes. 

5. Tomato Paste

Tomato Paste

Tomato paste is also made very similarly to tomato puree. For a tomato paste, tomatoes are cooked and strained for long hours until a concentrated paste is obtained. 

Tomato paste has a thick texture with a rich sweet flavor of tomatoes. You might have to be careful while adding due to the concentrated flavor, which may overpower other ingredients.

Tomato paste is perfect for making sauces or soups. Except for the texture, tomato paste works really well as a substitute for fire-roasted tomatoes. 

6. Roasted Bell Peppers

Roasted Bell Peppers

Roasted bell peppers can be an option worth considering to use in lieu of fire-roasted tomatoes. They have the same fiery flavor with undertones of sweetness similar to fire-roasted tomatoes.

You will have to be mindful of the less water content while using roasted bell peppers. Add enough water or any liquid of your preference to emulate the flavor of fire-roasted tomatoes.

7. Tamarind Paste

Tamarind Paste

Tamarind paste can be a last resort to fire-roasted tomatoes. Tamarind, by nature, has a sweet, sour, and tangy taste. Its paste definitely will have the intense, concentrated taste of tamarind.

To emulate the exact texture of fire-roasted tomatoes might not be possible with tamarind paste. However, the sweet and sour taste of fire-roasted tomatoes can be easily achieved. You can adjust the level of sourness with a sweetener of your choice.


So, that was all about fire-roasted tomatoes and their best substitutes. I believe nothing can stop you now from trying out the fiery tomato mac and cheese recipe now. Be sure you let me know which among these substitutes you used to help your fellow foodies or cooks who visit here. See you soon!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.