7 Best Caraway Seed Substitutes You Can Use

Note- This post may contain affiliate links, we earn from qualifying purchases made on our website. If you make a purchase through links from this website, we may get a small share of the sale from Amazon and other similar affiliate programs.

Looking for a good caraway seed substitute? Caraway seeds are an important part of Asian cuisine. It has a unique taste and aroma that adds a subtle flavor to the dish. 

Caraway seeds

Finding out we’re out of an ingredient in the middle of cooking is one of the worst feelings. It’s much worse if it’s something like a carraway with few replacements. In these circumstances, a decent caraway substitute is required.

Even though there aren’t many caraway seed substitutes, some work great as caraway seed substitutes. Fennel, dill, aniseed, nigella, and star anise are some of the best caraway seed substitutes.

Caraway seeds are an amazing ingredient considering their taste and health benefits. However, if you do not know much about caraway seeds, the next section is for you. In the next section, we will try to cover everything one needs to know about caraway seeds.

Quick Peek: Caraway Seeds

Caraway seed

Caraway seeds are nothing less than a bomb in a shell. It has a unique taste, aroma, and lots of health benefits. This section is all about deeply exploring caraway seeds. So let’s go?

What Are Caraway Seeds?

Caraway seeds are also called meridian fennel and Persian cumin. These are small seeds of caraway plants. It is very small in size and has a crescent shape to it.

Caraway seeds are an important part of the culinary world. Not just seeds, even the other part of the plant, like leaves, are used for cooking and other medicinal purposes.

Describing Caraway Seeds: Flavor and Texture

Caraway seeds have a unique flavor. It tastes similar to that of anise with an undertone of licorice. It has a very fresh mouthfeel and something like a mint taste.

Caraway seeds have a crunchy texture and remain fresh in most dishes. It also has a fresh aroma that enhances the overall aroma of the entire dish.

Uses Of Caraway Seeds

Caraway seeds are widely used in baking. It imparts a fresh, crunchy taste and delicious flavor to the dish. If you ever had rye and soda bread, you must have bitten these caraway seeds in between.

Caraway seeds are also added to curries and gravies. It works well with chicken and fish dishes. When it comes to Indian cooking, caraway seeds are even added to sweets to enhance their flavors.

Roasted caraway seeds are sometimes added to drinks to give a twist to the flavor. Roasted carraway with some mint is all you need to give perfection to your otherwise normal mocktail.

Carraway, either raw or with sugar coating, is used as a mouth freshener. It’s difficult to find a south Indian curry without caraway seeds, so keep some on hand if you’re planning to prepare one.

Caraway Seeds On The Health Radar | Looking Through The Wellness Telescope

Caraway seeds, as I mentioned earlier, are loaded with health benefits. People use caraway seeds for many purposes. However, most of these are widely practiced across the globe without much scientific background.

First and foremost, caraway seeds are said to be good for gut health. It is taken as it is or as a powder to shoo away indigestion. It also works as a medicine against gastric issues. So when you have bloating next time, chew it away with caraway!

I don’t know whether it works! But it is widely used to suppress menstrual cramps. So if you have a severe cramp, take some caraway seed, boil it with water, and drink! If you give some caraway seeds to your girlfriends next time.

Even though it’s so tiny, it has many more health benefits. It is like many seeds out there that have many vitamins and minerals that will help you have good hair and skin.

Why Should We Substitute Caraway Seeds?

After reading so many good things about caraway seed, you must have this question in your mind. Well, to tell the truth, even I wouldn’t want to substitute caraway seeds with anything else.

However, if you are someone who is allergic to caraway seeds, you might need to find a caraway seed substitute that works just like caraway seeds in particular dishes.

Caraway seeds can be hard to find even after being widely used across. Or when you need it, your nearby supermarket could run out of it. Anything can happen; why take the risk when you have caraway seed substitutes?

I think these are some of the most genuine situations we might face, and we need caraway seed substitutes. The next section contains the crux of this article, which is the best caraway seed substitutes! Read thoroughly and choose accordingly! 

Other Food Substitutes You Can Try

7 Best Caraway Substitutes 

In this section, we are presenting you with some of our favorite caraway seed substitutes. 

1. Fennel Seeds

Fennel Seeds

Fennel seeds, just like caraway seeds, are small in size and have a licorice taste. It can be easily used as a caraway seed.

Fennel seeds not only share the taste profile with caraway seeds but also have health benefits. Just like caraway seeds, fennel seeds are also helpful in curing bloating and gastric troubles.

However, fennel seeds have a bolder taste than of caraway seeds. But it won’t affect the overall taste of the dish. Therefore you can easily substitute 1 teaspoon of fennel seeds with 1 teaspoon of caraway seeds in your curries and gravies.

2. Dill Seeds

Dill Seed

Dill seeds are small in size and have a flat tear-like structure. When eaten raw, it almost mimics the caraway seed’s taste, and hence it can be used as a caraway seed substitute.

Dill seeds have a strong flavor profile. It has a licorice flavor with a tangy twist. It can be used in curries, gravies as well as in baking. When used as a caraway seed substitute, one can follow the standard 1:1 ratio.

3. Aniseed

Aniseed

Aniseed has a sweet taste with a licorice undertone. It can be used to add flavor to beverages and food items. Therefore when we need a caraway seed substitute, use aniseed.

Aniseed is often mistaken for fennel seed. However, aniseed is smaller than fennel seed and has a sweet taste. It has been in use for ages; however, nowadays, people aren’t giving enough importance to aniseed.

Aniseed also has a strong fresh aroma. It can be used as a caraway seed substitute in baked goods as well as in alcoholic beverages. While used as a caraway seed substitute, follow the standard 1:1 ratio.

4. Nigella Seed

Nigella seeds

Nigella seeds have a smokey taste with subdued onion and oregano flavor. However, if you are cooking a meat dish, choose nigella seed over anything else as a caraway seed substitute.

Even though nigella seeds have a prominent smoky flavor, they also have a fresh licorice-like aroma, like caraway seed. This makes it a worthy caraway seed substitute.

It is small, like caraway seeds, and is black in color. It is packed with many nutrients. Therefore, it can be sprinkled over your salads, or you can cook and eat it. When used as a caraway seed substitute, follow the 1:1 ratio.

5. Star Anise

Star Anise

Star Anise has a licorice taste with an overpowering sweetness. It can be used as a caraway seed substitute in a couple of dishes.

Star anise looks like a small brown star. It has a very strong flavor profile and pungent smell. But since it has a licorice taste, it can be used as a caraway seed substitute.

However, when replacing, start by adding a small amount of star anise to your food and adjusting the flavor according to your preference.

6. Dried Oregano

dried oregano

Dried oregano has a sweet and ministry aroma. It can be used as a good caraway seed substitute in sauces and curries.

As you know, oregano is a constant in Italian and Mediterranean food. It has a peppery taste and minty aroma. Just a teaspoon of dried oregano can positively change the whole mood of the food.

So if you are cooking something with a savory twist, use dried oregano as a caraway seed substitute; while replacing, use one teaspoon of dried oregano for one teaspoon of caraway seeds.

7. Cumin seeds

Cumin

Cumin seeds have a peppery flavor with a citrusy aroma. It also has a slight licorice flavor like caraway seeds; hence it can be used as a caraway seed substitute in dishes.

Cumin seeds are one of the most easily available caraway seed substitutes. It can be safely added to sauces as well as in curries. However, cumin has a slightly different flavor profile than that caraway seeds.

Therefore before adding, do a quick taste test. While replacing, use half a spoon of cumin seeds for one teaspoon of caraway seeds.

Short Recap For Best Caraway Seed Substitutes

I am sure that by now, you must have gone through all the above-mentioned substitutes for caraway seeds. However, I know some of you might still be confused about which one to use. So, I have broken it down further into three categories.

Best Caraway seed Substitutes In Terms Of Flavor and Texture –

  1. Dill Seeds
  2. Fennel Seed

Most Easily Accessible Caraway Seed Substitutes

  1. Cumin Seed
  2. Nigella Seed

Best Caraway Seed Substitutes Should Be Least Considered –

  1. Star Anise
  2. Oregano

How To Substitute Caraway Seeds

Caraway seeds

Caraway Seed Substitutes.

Caraway seeds are an important part of Asian cuisine. It has a unique taste and aroma that adds a subtle flavor to the food. Even though there aren't many caraway seed substitutes  some work great as caraway seed substitutes. . Fennel, dill, aniseed, nigella, and star anise are some of the best caraway seed substitutes.
5 from 1 vote

Ingredients
  

  • Fennel Seeds
  • Dill Seeds
  • Nigella Seed
  • Star Anise
  • Dried Oregano
  • Cumin Seeds

Instructions
 

  • Go through the substitutes and see which one seems fit for the recipe.
  • Collect your ingredients and use your preferred substitute.
  • Use the substitute in the required amount and proceed to make the dish according to the recipe.
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Final Word

As we near the end of this post, I hope it has assisted you in determining the finest caraway seed substitute for your recipe. Caraway seeds might be difficult to come by. Substitutes can, however, replicate the flavor of this seed.

All of the substitution options shown in this article are excellent substitutes for caraway seeds. You can choose your substitution based on what works best in your recipe and your unique flavor preferences, and I am confident you will enjoy it!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Can I substitute cumin for caraway seeds?

Yes. Cumin seeds are more flavorful than caraway seeds. Therefore use half a teaspoon of cumin seeds for one teaspoon of caraway seeds.


What tastes like caraway seeds?

Fennel seeds, dill seeds, aniseed, nigella seed, and star anise are some of the seeds that taste almost like caraway seeds.

Can I omit caraway seeds?

Fennel seeds, dill seeds, aniseed, nigella seed, and star anise are seeds that can mimic the caraway seeds’ flavor. If you don’t have any of these in hand, it is better to omit caraway seeds.

What can I use instead of caraway seeds in rye bread?

Dill, aniseed, and fennel seed are some things you can try as a caraway seed substitute in rye bread.

What does caraway taste like?

Caraway seeds have a unique flavor. It tastes similar to that of anise with an undertone of licorice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating