Bruster’s Ice Cream Menu with Prices [Updated June 2024]

Bruster’s fresh homemade ice cream has been taking care of the sweet cravings in the United States since 1989. Well, if you haven’t tried their ice cream yet, then I must tell you that you are missing out on the most delicious thick and creamy ice creams. They are made of natural ingredients and are truly one of a kind. 

Bruster's Ice Cream

The brand offers 150 varieties of flavors, out of which 24 selected varieties are served rotationally along with cakes, pies, sundaes, splits, and even shakes and freezes! 

The best part? Bruster’s has nearly 200 independently owned outlets in 22 States and Guyana, which means you don’t have to travel far and wide to get your favorite scoop of ice cream!

Bruster’s Ice Cream Menu with Prices

I’m sure you are excited to explore Bruster’s ice cream menu by now. To make things easier for you, we have added a drop-down option mentioned below that will expand Bruster’s ice cream menu tables. It will help you explore vegan, keto-friendly, and gluten-free options. 

Further, you can also jump to your preferred menu category so that you don’t have to keep scrolling!

Sundaes | Shakes/Blasts | Take Home | Cakes & Pies |

Sundaes

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Kid’s Dirt Sundae$4.19440NoYesNoNo
Kid’s Dino Sundae$4.19430NoYesNoNo
Hot Fudge Brownie Smoothie$7.991000NoYesNoNo
Banana Split$7.991220NoYesNoNo
Turtle Sundae$7.29970NoYesNoNo
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae$7.291060NoYesNoNo
Regular Sundae$5.89540NoYesNoNo
Strawberry Sundae$7.99281NoYesNoNo

Shakes/Blasts

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Small Milkshake 16oz$5.49620-680NoNoNoNo
Regular Milkshake 22oz$6.09750-830NoNoNoNo
Large Milkshake 32oz$7.491150-1280NoNoNoNo
Small Blast 16oz$6.79830-1060NoYesNoNo
Regular Blast 22oz$7.791150-1360NoYesNoNo
Freeze 22oz$5.29460-600NoYesNoNo

Take Home

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Half Gallon$19.191760-4480YesYesNoNo
Quart$12.19880-2240YesYesNoNo
2 Pint Special$12.001000YesYesNoNo
2 Quart Special$20.001420YesYesNoNo
Pint$7.29420-1120YesYesNoNo
Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Single$4.49300YesYesNoYes
Oreo Ice Cream Sandwich Single 6 pack$21.99300YesYesNoYes

Cakes & Pies For Immediate Pickup

Item NamePriceCaloriesVeganVegetarianGluten – FreeKeto
Cake (Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream)$35.99239NoNoNoNo
Cake (Chocolate Ice Cream)$35.99360NoNoNoNo
Cake (Chocolate Raspberry Truffle Ice Cream)$35.99233NoNoNoNo
Cake (Oreo Ice Cream)$35.99300NoNoNoNo
Cake (Strawberry Ice Cream)$35.99400NoNoNoNo
Pie (Key Lime Pie Ice Cream)$25.99291NoNoNoYes
Pie (Oreo Ice Cream )$25.99290NoNoNoYes
Pie (White Turtle Ice Cream)$25.99215NoNoNoYes

Popular Items On Bruster’s Menu

Bruster's Ice Cream

1. Cherry Vanilla 

There is no denying that classics are given a special place on the menu because of their timeless appeal. Therefore, if you are in the mood for one, I recommend you to go for Bruster’s Cherry Vanilla ice cream. This ice cream is popular as it has the right amount of sweetness to it and the quintessential vanilla flavor. 

Moreover, it features whole sweet pieces of Maraschino cherry which makes for a delightful combination that’s hard to resist. 

In my opinion, this ice cream tastes the best in a waffle cone as it provides the right amount of crunch to compliment the creaminess of the ice cream.

2. Key Lime Pie

Bruster’s Key Lime Pie is my all time summer favorite ice cream. It brings together tangy and tart flavors of key lime with graham cracker swirls that makes for an indulgent and refreshing choice.  

While you can enjoy this ice cream in a cup or cone, I feel it tastes the best when served on a graham cracker crust. That’s because its chewy texture compliments the creaminess of the ice cream. I can guarantee that you will surely fall more and more in love with this popular ice cream with every bite. 

3. Peanut Butter Puddles

One of the flavors I always recommend people to try is Peanut Butter Puddles at Bruster’s. This ice cream is popular because of its dream combination of vanilla, peanut butter, and chocolate that makes me drool just thinking about it. 

When you bite into this ice cream, you first experience the silky and creamy smoothness of a good handmade vanilla ice cream. But the experience gets even more interesting when puddles of peanut butter melt into your mouth and crunchy chocolate krispies offer a contrasting texture. 

4. Apple Dumpling Sundae

If you wish to have the ultimate sundae experience, then I suggest you try Bruster’s most popular sundae – Apple Dumpling Sundae. It truly offers a mind blowing ice cream experience. The specialty of this sundae is that it comes with a whole apple wrapped in a warm and flaky dumpling that’s baked to perfection.

It is further topped with two generous scoops of sweet, thick, and creamy cinnamon ice cream. But that’s not all! They come drizzled with a luscious cinnamon sauce that compliments the flavor of apple and enhances its overall taste profile. 

5. Mixed Berry Cheesecake With Graham 

Bruster’s Mixed Berry Cheesecake With Graham is a taste test approved option. True to its name, this delight features a thick and cream cheesecake ice cream folded with sweet blueberry and strawberry swirls. 

However, the part that I love the most about this ice cream is the addition of graham cracker ribbons that add a crunchy contrast to the creamy ice cream. This ice cream is what experiencing bliss means!  

6. Waffle Bowl

Waffle Bowls are also a great option to try at Bruster’s. They are used as a base to create delectable sundaes. One of the reasons they are so popular is because they are freshly-baked in the house. 

You can ask them to be filled with any ice cream of your choice. Moreover, you also get to choose your favorite topping that includes candies and cookies. I also find this sweet treat to be the perfect sharing option!

7. Birthday Cake

Bruster’s know how to make their customers happy. Hence, they offer unique ice cream flavors like the Birthday Cake ice cream that makes for an exceptional sweet treat. As the name suggests, this ice cream is prepared with Bruster’s homemade yellow cake batter ice cream that offers the same taste as a vanilla birthday cake.

Further, to make things more appetizing, it comes added with sweet blue icing and topped with colorful rainbow sprinkles that appeal to all age groups. All these components make this ice cream quite popular among customers and the perfect option to enjoy instead of a traditional birthday cake. 

8. Orange Sherbet

Sherbets are the best cooling beverages to beat the heat. Therefore, I suggest you try out the Orange Sherbet at Bruster’s. It is famous for its refreshing orange flavor and creamy texture.

The best part about it is that you can enjoy this offering from Bruster’s in many ways. For example, you can ask it to be served in a waffle cone, cup, pint, or as a part of a sundae with any topping of your choice.  

9. Blasts

Bruster’s is also popular for its Blasts. This decadent sweet treat combines cookies and candies in creamy vanilla ice cream, and is served in a glass.  

The best part? You have the choice of choosing the mix-ins from a variety of options like brownie bites, Nestle Crunch, Twix, nuts, cookie dough, M&Ms, Reese’s and more! Therefore, I recommend you to try this menu item for its delicious taste and the convenience of carrying it anywhere. 

10. Freeze

Ice creams are sure great at Bruster’s, however, you must try their Freeze as well if you are looking for a colorful drink to brighten up your day. The unique feature about them is that you can pick any sherbet, Italian Ice, and sorbet to be frozen. 

Then, your selected option is blended with Sprite. In my opinion, their lemon sorbet is the ultimate! Its refreshing citrusy notes and icy texture makes for the best combo to enjoy during the summer season. 

What Are People Asking About Bruster’s Ice Cream?

Current Deals Running At Bruster’s Ice Cream

Bruster's Ice Cream

At Bruster’s, you can also make your pocket happy with attractive deals while treating your taste buds. Allow me to tell you about them all that I found when I last checked their website

  1. Customer Appreciation Deal – Once a year during the spring season, Bruster’s offers a free single scoop of waffle cone to customers who visit the store wearing their night clothes. You can check for this deal by visiting your nearest participating Bruster’s store. However, you must remember that this offer is valid for a single person, per visit.  
  2. Banana Thursday BYOB – If you love bananas, then you must take note of this Thursday deal at Bruster’s that allows you to purchase a banana split for half the price. However, the catch is that you take your banana and they provide the ice cream and the toppings.
  3. Doggies Sundaes – You don’t have to share your sweet treats with your furry friends anymore because Bruster’s is here to take care of their needs. All you need to do is visit the store with your dog and they will be rewarded with a free doggie sundae. 
  4. Baby Cones – Bruster’s is making sure to leave no one out. Therefore, they are also giving out free baby cones to the smallest members of the family who are less than 40 inches tall. 

Haven’t all these deals given you a reason already to visit Bruster’s? Then go ahead and order your favorite ice cream along with freebies. Moreover, you can also avail more benefits by signing up for Bruster’s rewards program. The rewards earned are applicable for redemption within 90 days. 

Furthermore, you can also avail the benefits of Bruster’s gift cards by making purchases depending on the amount loaded in the card. However, it should be noted that you will have to pay any amount that exceeds the gift card value.   

How We’ve Verified, We’re This Data

We at TheFoodXP are dedicated to providing you with the most authentic information about Bruster’s menu items and prices. Hence, we have a dedicated team that verifies the data from the restaurants’ official websites.

But that’s not all! To be extra sure, all the information is cross-verified with leading delivery platforms to avoid any discrepancies. However, we still recommend you cross-check the menu items and their details, as they may vary from location to location. 

To be sure of the information that we provide, you can read more about how we update our menu along with their prices.  

Other Restaurants’ Menus That We’ve Covered

If ice cream is your go-to dessert, then we have many more ice cream restaurant recommendations for you to try. Just like the amazing flavors of ice cream from Baskin-Robbins, Ben & Jerry’s, and Dairy Queen

Likewise, you can try delectable shakes available at Culver’s and Cold Stone Creamery

Conclusion

I’m sure I’m excited to visit Bruster’s with all my recommendations. So, go ahead and try them out. The nutritional information in this article will help you find the right menu items according to your dietary needs. 

However, you should have a good look at the FAQ section, which provides answers to many commonly asked questions about the restaurant that you may also have. After your visit, please share your experience with us in the comments section below. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *