Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe (Photos + Video)

Note- This post may contain affiliate links, we earn from qualifying purchases made on our website. If you make a purchase through links from this website, we may get a small share of the sale from Amazon and other similar affiliate programs.

Bobby Flay Potato Salad is the best option for your picnics and barbecues, and also, how can I forget Thanksgiving? Prepare this fantastic salad to impress your guests. So now let’s dive into the further details.

Bobby Flay Style Potato Salad

Bobby Flay makes this salad by using a variety of ingredients to build a creamy texture and tangy taste with a hint of sweetness, which makes it more tasty.

Still here? Go ahead and find all the related queries with all the information and details, along with the additional information that will help you with the process of making this recipe. 

Is This The Exact Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe?

Yes, this is the exact Bobby Flay Potato Salad recipe, which is prepared by our Chef Jasbir with potatoes, onion, scallion, cayenne, chipotle pepper puree, and ripe tomatoes, along with some ingredients like mayonnaise and Dijon mustard.

Initially, we were skeptical about how it would taste, but it was the most comforting and refreshing salad. 

Easy Potato Salad Recipe

How Is Bobby Flay Potato Salad Different From Regular Potato Salad?

Bobby Flay Potato Salad typically features a few distinguishing elements when compared to a regular potato salad:

  • South Western Flavors – Bobby Flay often adds a South Western twist to his potato salad using ingredients like cilantro leaves and lime juice to give it a zesty and slightly spicy flavor. In contrast, regular potato salad doesn’t use it.
  • Chipotle Pepper Puree And Mayonnaise – Bobby Flay uses chipotle pepper puree and mayonnaise to prepare the dressing, but regular potato salad recipe doesn’t use them.
  • Seasoning – Bobby Flay uses salt and pepper to season his potato salad, but the regular one uses Kosher salt instead of ordinary salt.

Why You’ll Love This Potato Salad Recipe?

Bobby Flay Potato Salad is going to be one of your favorite due to the specific reasons mentioned above:

  • Easy To Make – This Bobby Flay Potato Salad needs some cooking and mixing, and Voila! Your salad is ready to serve. Yes, cooking will take some time, but peeps have patience. It’s going to be epic.
  • Healthy – Along with the easy process, you will find this recipe super healthy. It provides you with a lot of health benefits that keep you healthy.
  • Creamy – Ingredients like mayonnaise and Dijon mustard make this salad so creamy that you will surely love it, especially if you love dishes filled with cream.
  • Garnishing – This potato salad is best when garnished with various ingredients like scallions and cilantro leaves, which hit your salad with a green and refreshing look.
Serving Bobby Flay Potato Salad

Is This Potato Salad Vegan, Gluten And Keto-Free?

Check the further details mentioned, and you will find out whether they are vegan, gluten and keto-free or not:

  • Vegan Friendly – Bobby Flay Potato Salad is not vegan-friendly as it contains mayonnaise which is made with egg yolks. But you can make this vegan-friendly by swapping it with a plant-based mayo.
  • Gluten-Free – Bobby Flay Potato Salad is a clear choice for people on a strict gluten-free diet. So feel free to eat this salad.
  • Keto Friendly – Potato Salad is unsuitable for people who follow a keto-free diet as it contains potatoes, which are high in carbs, and this keto diet calls for a no-fat and no-carb diet. But substituting potatoes with cauliflower works best on a keto diet.

Equipment Required For Bobby Flay Potato Salad

  • Pot – Boil the potatoes in a pot filled with cold water.
  • Bowl – To prepare the salad dressing, combine all the ingredients in a bowl.
  • Knife – A knife will help in chopping the onions and also to cut the potatoes.
  • Wooden Spoon – Mix all the ingredients with the help of a wooden spoon.
Bobby Flay Potato Salad Ingredients

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Ingredients 

  • Mayonnaise – Mayonnaise works best in a creamy salad dressing, providing a sour and tangy taste. 
  • Potatoes – Potatoes are the primary and the star ingredient to prepare this salad. 
  • Ripe Tomatoes – Fully ripened tomatoes are plump and juicy and have a deep red color. It adds a sweet along with a tangy taste.
  • Cilantro Leaves – Use cilantro leaves to add a more green effect and a peppery and spicy taste.
  • Scallions – Garnish scallions for a fresh green salad. It will bring out an aromatic blend of flavors to your salad. 
  • Onion – Red onions are best for this potato salad, so add thinly chopped onions.
  • Garlic – Use finely chopped garlic for a buttery and savory taste.
  • Salt & Black Pepper – Salt and black pepper are always best for seasonings to enhance the flavors.
  • Dijon Mustard – Dijon mustard is best to hit your salad with a savory and spicy taste.
  • Lime Juice – To make your salad at your best, add lime juice, giving you a sour taste.
  • Cayenne Powder – Cayenne powder adds a fruity aroma and spicy solid flavor.
  • Chipotle Pepper Puree – Chipotle pepper puree will boast a rich, dense flavor with a perfect balance of smokiness and subtle sweetness.

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Ingredients Substitutes

  • Chipotle Pepper Puree – We’ve used chipotle pepper puree, but if you don’t have that, substitute it with smoked paprika. It’s the closest replacement for chipotle pepper puree.
  • Cilantro Leaves – There are a lot of other substitutes for cilantro leaves that can be used in place of cilantro leaves. Some are Thai basil and dill. Also, parsley is the most available substitute so you can use it.
  • Cayenne Powder – We’ve used cayenne powder, but instead, you can use many different options that are readily available in your kitchen. Some are paprika, red chili flakes, or chili powder.
Potato Salad Recipe

Can You Use The Potatoes Without Peeling Them?

Yes, you can make this potato salad without peeling them. I suggest you make it without peeling their skin off, as they will provide you with a lot of nutrients and fiber, which is good for your health.

But remember that you should scrub the potatoes thoroughly under water to remove dirt.

Moreover, to make this salad, use Russet potatoes, Yukon potatoes, or red potatoes as they have a thinner skin, which are more tender and accessible.

Do Bobby Flay Cool Potatoes Before Adding To The Dressing?

Bobby Flay only cools the potatoes after adding the dressing to the mashed potatoes, and he also recommends that we use hot potatoes before adding the sauce. 

Potatoes, when hot, are absorbent, which means they will absorb more flavors of the dressing, resulting in flavorful potato salad. 

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Preparation And Cooking Time

Preparation TimeResting TimeCooking TimeTotal Time
10 Minutes10 Minutes20 Minutes40 Minutes
How To Make Bobby Flay Potato Salad At Home

How To Check If Potatoes Are Perfectly Boiled?

Here are some of the easiest ways through which you can check if potatoes are perfectly boiled or not. To know them, go through the guide mentioned below:

  • Test Them With A Fork or Knife – One of the easiest ways is to pierce them with a fork or knife. If the fork or knife slides in easily, then you are done, but if you meet resistance, then you must boil them for further minutes.
  • Check By Looking At The Color – If the potatoes are done, then they should be light and fluffy, but if they are still hard and white, that means they should be cooked for a longer time.
  • Check By Smelling Them – If potatoes are properly boiled, they should have a mild and earthy aroma. But if they are sour or have an off odor, they are not edible.
  • Test By Touching Them – If the potatoes are warm to touch, then they are done, but if they are way hotter, then they are overly cooked.

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe Steps 

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 1

Step 1- Start by pouring mayo in a bowl.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 2

Step 2- Add Dijon sauce along with cayenne powder in mayonnaise.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 3

Step 3- Mix lime juice and chipotle pepper puree to the mixture.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 4

Step 4- Season the mixture with salt and pepper and mix it thoroughly.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 5

Step 5- Put chopped scallions and garlic in the bowl.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 6

Step 6- Now add onion to the mixture.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 7

Step 7- Add some ripe tomatoes to it.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 8

Step 8- Mix the ingredients together and keep potatoes aside.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 9

Step 9- Finally time for the star ingredient to be added.


Bobby Flay Potato Salad Step 10

Step 10- After mixing the potatoes with the mixture, now at last garnish it with cilantro leaves.


Bobby Flay Style Potato Salad

Step 11- Your Bobby Flay Potato Salad is ready.

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe Video

Here is the video that we’ve made on our YouTube channel for this Bobby Flay Potato Salad recipe.

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe 🥔 🥗

Tips To Make This Potato Salad Better

This potato salad can be made better, you just have to follow the further tips, and Voila! Your yummiest potato salad is ready to eat:

  • Both the potatoes should be overcooked and undercooked. Overcooked potatoes will make the salad more mushy, and undercooked potatoes will make it hard to chew.
  • Drain the potatoes properly, as excess water will make them watery.
  • If you want your salad to be well-seasoned, then make sure you season the water with salt, as the potatoes will absorb the salt and become more flavorful.
  • You must be using the correct type of potato. Use waxy potatoes as they have a low starch content, which prevents them from getting mushy and gives a firm texture.
  • Make sure you let the potato salad sit for a few minutes before serving so that the flavors are perfectly melded in the salad, making it more flavorful.

How Will This Bobby Flay Potato Salad Look & Taste Like?

Bobby Flay Potato Salad is generally made with mayonnaise-based dressing with extra flavors of other ingredients. Included ingredients are Dijon mustard, chipotle pepper puree, lime juice, and cayenne powder that builds a spicy and tangy taste in the salad. 

Moreover, when this salad is made correctly, it tends to be very creamy and refreshing due to the garnished cilantro leaves on top of it, which creates a slight green effect.

Homemade Bobby Flay Potato Salad

Why Does Your Potatoes Melt And Turn Oily?

Potatoes may melt and turn oily due to a few reasons. To know them, go ahead and read:

  • Don’t Cook Them in Too Much Oil – Cooking potatoes in a large quantity of oil can make them oily and lead to a melted texture as they absorb the oil more than needed.
  • Don’t Over Cook The Potatoes – Over-cooking can melt your potatoes and may turn oily, so be careful about cooking the potatoes at the right time. 
  • Don’t Freeze Them For A Long Time – If the potatoes are kept frozen for a longer time, then there’s a certainty that they may absorb too much oil, which will turn them oily and can melt quickly.

Why Is Your Potato Salad Dry?

There could be a few reasons behind the dryness of your salad; check out further:

  • Increase The Quantity Of Mayo – Less mayonnaise could be the first reason. If you use a lesser amount of mayonnaise, then your salad may turn out dry.
  • Avoid Tossing Them Too Much – Tossing the salad too much can lead to a dry salad, which will not taste as good as you want.
  • Don’t Use Too Many Veggies – If you use veggies in a large amount, then it can also make your salad dry. The amount of dressing will automatically be reduced because of adding too much veggies to the salad.
  • Don’t Use Too Much Lime Juice – Adding too much lime juice can also make it dry, as it helps to balance the richness of the mayonnaise.

Why Is Your Potato Salad Watery?

Your potato salad may turn watery because you are making these mistakes:

  • Using too much mayonnaise to prepare the dressing can give you a watery consistency, so avoid using mayo in a large quantity.
  • Not draining the potatoes properly, be sure that you drain the potatoes properly in a colander. Any excess moisture can make it watery.
  • If you use the wrong type of potatoes, some potatoes release too much moisture, resulting in a watery form.

Moreover, over-cooking can also give you a watery form of potato salad; cook them until they are tender and not mushy. 

How To Make Potato Salad At Home

Why Does Your Potato Salad Turn Brown?

Potato salad turns brown when oxygen reacts with the starch in potatoes. Not only brown, it can also turn gray or even black. To know more, check out further guide:

  • If you do not keep the salad for chilling immediately, it will turn brown; as soon as you keep the salad for the chilling process, the oxidation process will occur slowly.
  • Don’t cut the potatoes too early, as the starch present in the potato will react with oxygen and end up turning brown.
  • Cutting the potatoes early can also turn them brown as the starch reacts with the oxygen, which starts the oxidation process.

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Nutritional Values

Calories358 kcal
Total Fat21 g
Cholesterol170 mg
Sodium1323 mg
Potassium635 mg
Total Carbohydrates28 g
Protein6.7 g

Tips To Make This Recipe More Healthy

You can make this salad healthier; go through the further tips and follow them, and there you go with a tasty and healthy potato salad.

  • Reducing the amount of dressing will make the salad healthier as the sauce has more fat content.
  • Use more veggies to make this salad more healthy. More veggies will provide you with more health benefits, including fiber.
  • Ignore using mayonnaise; use Greek yogurt instead. It will create a healthier version.
  • Sprinkle some nuts as per your preferences, as it will build in a crunch along with some health benefits.
Chef Bobby Flay Potato Salad

Can You Make This Potato Salad Ahead Of Time

Yes, you can make this Bobby Flay Potato Salad ahead of time. Please prepare this salad in advance as this will let the flavors of the dressing settle in properly, making the salad more flavorful.

An add-on tip for you all: don’t freeze this potato salad, as the taste and texture will taste off when it defrosts.

How Can You Store This Recipe?

Want to eat this recipe on a super hectic day? Make it in advance and store it in the following ways to keep it fresh and safe.

  • Room Temperature –  Bobby Flay Potato Salad can be kept safely at room temperature but only for one to two hours max, but make you cover it with a cling film.
  • Air-tight Container – Before storing the salad in the refrigerator, transfer it to an air-tight container for a few hours.
  • Refrigerator – Leftovers of this potato salad can be safely stored in the fridge for up to five days. But be very sure you are keeping it properly. Use cling film or a sealed container to the salad properly.

What To Serve With Bobby Flay Potato Salad?

  1. Paula Deen Zucchini Bread: Consuming this salad with bread will make the best pair. Creamy potato salad and dry Zucchini bread, what more can you ask for? It’ll enhance the flavors and make your meal perfect.
  2. Paula Deen Meatloaf: A meatloaf with this delicious potato salad will make a perfect duo for an ideal meal, along with creating a different taste and flavors.
  3. Jamie Oliver Gnocchi: Amp up the flavors of your meal by pairing this potato salad with Gnocchi. It will add a twist to your feed, making it more flavorful.
  4. Gordon Ramsay Tacos: Tacos and this Potato Salad can be more asked for a delicious or fulfilling meal.
  5. Jamie Oliver Steak Marinade: Potato Salad and Steak Marinade is a perfect fusion to serve on any special occasion to impress your guests. So go for it.

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Printable Version

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe

Bobby Flay Potato Salad is the best option for your picnics and barbecues, and also, how can I forget Thanksgiving? Prepare this fantastic salad to impress your guests.
5 from 1 vote
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Resting Time 10 minutes
Total Time 50 minutes
Course Chef’s Delight
Cuisine American
Servings 6
Calories 358 kcal

Equipment

  • Pot
  • Bowl
  • Knife
  • Wooden Spoon

Ingredients
  

  • 1 ½ cup Mayonnaise
  • 16 3-4 pounds Potatoes
  • 1 large Ripe Tomatoes
  • ¼ cup Cilantro Leaves
  • 3 chopped Scallions
  • 1 medium Red Onion
  • 4 cloves Garlic
  • Salt & Black Pepper
  • ¼ cup Dijon Mustard
  • 2 TBSP Lime Juice
  • ½ teaspoon Cayenne Powder
  • 2 TBSP Chipotle Pepper Puree

Instructions
 

  • Start by pouring mayo in a bowl.
  • Add Dijon sauce along with cayenne powder in mayonnaise.
  • Mix lime juice and chipotle pepper puree to the mixture.
  • Season the mixture with salt and pepper and mix it thoroughly.
  • Put chopped scallions and garlic in the bowl.
  • Now add onion to the mixture.
  • Add some ripe tomatoes to it.
  • Mix the ingredients altogether and keep potatoes aside.
  • Finally time for the star ingredient to be added.
  • After mixing the potatoes with the mixture, now at last garnish it with cilantro leaves.
  • Your Bobby Flay Potato Salad is ready.

Video

Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe 🥔 🥗

Notes

  • Both the potatoes should be overcooked and undercooked. Overcooked potatoes will make the salad more mushy, and undercooked potatoes will make it hard to chew.
  • Drain the potatoes properly, as excess water will make them watery.
  • If you want your salad to be well-seasoned, then make sure you season the water with salt, as the potatoes will absorb the salt and become more flavorful.
  • You must be using the correct type of potato. Use waxy potatoes as they have a low starch content, which prevents them from getting mushy and gives a firm texture.
  • Make sure you let the potato salad sit for a few minutes before serving so that the flavors are perfectly melded in the salad, making it more flavorful.

Nutrition

Calories: 358kcal | Carbohydrates: 28g | Protein: 6.7g | Fat: 21g | Cholesterol: 170mg | Sodium: 1323mg | Potassium: 635mg
Keyword Amazing Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe, Bobby Flay Potato Salad, Tasty Bobby Flay Potato Salad Recipe
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is potato salad dressing made of?

The potato salad dressing is made with mayonnaise, lime juice, ancho chili powder, mustard sauce, cayenne powder, tomatoes, garlic, cilantro leaves, jalapeno, salt, and black pepper.

Do you have to put eggs in the potato salad?

No! You don’t put eggs in the potato salad.

What goes with potato salad?

You can enjoy potato salad with hamburgers, chicken, steak, baked ham, and also grilled fish.

How do you thicken potato salad?

Add mayonnaise to potato salad to make it thick and creamy.

Do you eat potato salad cold?

Potato salad is mostly served cold.

How do you not overcook potatoes for potato salad?1

To cook perfect potatoes, get them into cold water and then cook. They should be fully submerged.

Conclusion 

So this was it for Bobby Flay Potato Salad; I’ll be back with more delicious recipes like this. So, for now, try this recipe by following the instructions mentioned. Above that, every information and detail about the recipe is mentioned, so what’s stopping you? Go for it. 

For more Chef Delight recipes, go through the guide cited further. Crispy Grilled Potato Salad Recipe, Authentic Bobby Flay German Potato Salad Recipe, Bobby Flay Apple Salad Recipe, Perfect Bobby Flay Chicken Salad recipe, Bobby Flay Pasta Salad Recipe, Bobby Flay Corn Salad Recipe, Bobby Flay Brussel Sprout Salad, Appetizing Bobby Flay Sweet Potato Recipe.

About The Author

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating