14 Best Beef Consommé Substitutes You Should Try

beef consommé

Why did you need the list of best beef consomme substitutes? You might have wanted to make the soup of your life but are out of the flavorful beef consommé. Don’t worry; I got you! What if I told you I had a list of substitutes for beef consommé? 

Well, I’ve got just the thing for you. Some of the best beef consommé substitutes are beef broth, beef stock, bone broth, mushroom consommé, chicken consommé, and vegetable broth.

Beef consomme is one of those dishes that it’s mere thought makes your mouth water. Infused with delicate flavors and rich ingredients, this broth dish is one for the books. A perfect serve for fancy dinners, special occasions, weddings, etc., this dish is guaranteed to win everyone’s hearts.

It’s not fair to have a classic dinner feast without including beef consomme in it. But what to do when you don’t have the ingredients for it and, further, can’t cook it? Shh, don’t tell anyone, and follow me for a deeper insight into beef consomme and its substitutions.

Quick Peek: Beef Consommé

beef consommé

The following scribbles tell you what beef consomme is, its flavor, consistency, culinary uses, and health benefits.

What Is Consomme?

To get down to beef consomme and its substitutions, first, we need to know about “consomme.” Consomme is a French-originated clear soup dish that can be served hot, chilled, or in gelatinous form. It is made by using carrots, celery, onion, tomatoes, egg whites, ground meats, or other kinds of protein. 

Consomme’s flavor is usually concentrated and has great variation to it. The aromatics provided by this dish are dominated by the spices and vegetables used in the consomme. Now that we know what consomme is, we can get into further detail about beef consomme.

What Is Beef Consomme?

Beef consomme is a rich, flavorful liquid that is cooked by making a clear broth out of beef bones, egg whites, and water. Beef consomme can be served as a stand-alone dish, usually as a starter. You can also add spices like pepper and garnish it with bay leaves, etc. 

Describing Beef Consomme: Flavor and Consistency

Beef consomme is a delicate soup dish that is usually clear and is dark brown in color. Since the broth is clarified to remove impurities, the resultant consomme is clean in flavor and consistency. It has a concentrated beef flavor (obviously) and thick consistency. 

Uses of Beef Consomme

Beef consommé has a rich and concentrated flavor. That is why it is best suited to be a stand-alone dish. It can also be added to various side dishes, soups, etc., as an ingredient.

This further enhances the overall flavors of the dish and adds a certain depth to it. Beef consommé can also be used to make aspic. Aspic is a type of jelly having a savory taste and is often made from meat stock. 

Beef Consomme on The Health Radar | Looking Through The Wellness Telescope

Beef consomme can have a healing impact on your digestive tract. It strengthens your bones and reduces inflammation. It is good for restoring sleep and is extremely beneficial for weight loss. It also aids in the production of blood cells and boosts the functioning of the nervous system.

Why Should We Substitute Beef Consomme?

Beef consomme is an intensely delicious soup dish. Though it can be easily made, we opt to buy it considering the busy lives we live. If it is not available in the nearby grocery store or if you are out of time to go to a store, you need the help of the best beef consomme substitutes, right?

Best beef consomme substitutes will come in handy if you wish to relish the taste and flavor of beef consomme without actually using it. Also, you can up the game by successfully replacing beef consomme with a bunch of substitutes without anyone noticing.

So, shall we look into the best beef consomme substitutes so that you are ready to take your cooking game to the next level?

14 Best Beef Consommé Substitutes

Beef consomme is a dish which can be difficult to knock out of the park. If you’re not careful while cooking it, the flavors can get messed up. So, here’s a list of beef consomme substitutes that can be of great use to you.

1. Beef Broth

beef broth

Beef broth is essentially a liquid mixture of beef simmered in liquid with added vegetables, herbs, and spices. Now don’t confuse beef broth with beef stock. Though beef stock and beef broth are made using similar ingredients, they differ from each other. Beef stock is made using bones, while broth makes use of vegetables as well.

Making beef broth is easy and less time-consuming. The broth has a less intense flavor. The broth can be cooked on low heat for a certain period of time. Heating beef broth on low flame for some time will help you get a flavor and texture similar to that of a beef consomme, making beef broth one of the best beef consomme substitutes.

2. Beef Stock

Beef Stock

Beef stock is prepared by slow and long cooking of bones to reduce and extract the nutrients from them. Vegetables or meat pieces are not usually added but can be done so. Even salt is minimally and rarely added.

You can make beef stock instantly by purchasing it from the market, packed in the form of beef bouillon cubes. But if you wanna go for a more flavorful stock, making it at home is the way to go.

Although preparing beef stock takes a lot of time, it is easier than beef consomme and is one of the best substitutes for beef consomme. You can also use beef stock in sauces, soups, etc.

3. Bone Broth

Bone broth

Bone broth can be made by boiling any sort of bones, preferably beef bones, and flavoring the liquid coming out of it. It takes a bit of time for the tissues of the bones to soften and to get the desired liquid. Bone broth can be substituted for beef consomme in a lot of dishes.

It has a texture a bit different than that of beef consomme. It is also very healthy and nutritious. Bone broth is a good replacement for beef consomme when it comes to soups and sauces.

4. Mushroom Consommé

Mushroom consommé

Mushroom consomme is a mouthwatering soup made of broth, egg whites, and water. It is made by simmering dried or wetland mushrooms with egg whites, salt, garlic, and black pepper. 

Mushroom consomme is a great vegetarian substitute for beef consomme. Mushrooms, having the same meaty texture, gives the consomme an umami flavor. You can also add other spices to make the consomme richer in flavor.

5. Chicken Consommé

Chicken consommé

Chicken consomme is a flavor-packed traditional soup dish made using chicken broth. Mostly, chicken carcass is used for the preparation, but sometimes legs or wings are also considered. It is golden and clear in appearance and is really aromatic. 

Chicken consomme can also be made using leftover veggies and chicken. Chicken consomme is similar to beef consomme in texture and taste, making it a good beef consomme substitute.

6. Vegetable Broth

Vegetable broth

Vegetable broth is another vegetarian substitute for beef consomme besides mushroom consomme. It is easy to make and is super delicious. You can use almost any vegetables you want. Vegetable broth has a mild, sweet flavor depending on the vegetables used to prepare the broth. The addition of garnishes and spices will make the broth more flavorful.

7. Au Jus

Au jus

Au Jus, just like consomme, is also a French-originated dish. It is a comprehensive term that refers to meat dishes made by using the juices secreted by the meat used while being cooked. It mainly refers to the broth or gravy part of the dish in which the meat is being served. 

Au Jus is used to prepare meat dishes making them soft and juicy. It can be combined with roasted chicken or ribs to make an excellent dipping sauce. Au Jus is similar to beef consomme and is thus a great substitute for it. 

8. Liquid Aminos

Liquid Aminos

Liquid aminos are made by either treating soybeans with an acid, breaking the proteins into amino acids (which are further neutralized with sodium bicarbonate), or by fermenting coconut sap with salt and water. 

Liquid aminos taste similar to soy sauce and have a salty, umami flavor with undertones of sweetness as well. Liquid aminos will be a considerable beef consomme substitute provided you get it – it might not be that easily available like other substitutes.

9. Bouillon Cubes

Bouillon Cubes

Bouillon cubes are also known as stock cubes or broth cubes. Basically, these are dehydrated broth formed into small cubes. These could be made from vegetable or meat stock with added seasoning agents. They render a rich, umami, salty flavor to dishes.

Although a variety of bouillon cubes are available, beef bouillon cubes can be used by mixing them with water to replace beef consomme in recipes. You will enjoy a profound beef flavor for sure!

10. Browning Sauce

Browning Sauce

Browning sauce is a condiment made by caramelizing (literally burning) sugar into a dark-brown colored liquid. Vegetable concentrates, and other seasoning agents can also be added. It is used in dishes to render a mild but unique sweet-sour flavor as well as an intense brown color. 

Browning sauce is a worthy substitute for beef consomme in soups and stews, considering the flavor and texture profiles. You shall have to be mindful of the color, though – you don’t want that to ruin your recipe.

11. Wine or Beer

Wine or Beer

You definitely might know that apart from being alcoholic beverages, wine and beer have culinary uses as well. They are at times used in recipes to impart a subtle sweet flavor.

Although wine and beer are not ideal replacements, they can be worthy beef consomme substitutes regardless of the textural differences. Wine or beer can substitute for beef consomme in stews or gravies.

12. Soy Sauce

Soy Sauce

Soy sauce is a popular Chinese condiment made using soybean, wheat, salt, and any fermenting agent. It is brownish-colored with a salty, umami savory flavor and a thick consistency. Soy sauce, with its umami flavor, can be a good beef consomme substitute. It can be diluted with water for a less intense flavor. 

13. Demi-Glace

Demi-Glace

A significant ingredient in French cuisine, demi-glace is a type of concentrated brown stock. It is made by combining brown sauce and brown stock (which could be chicken stock, vegetable stock, or beef stock) and reducing or concentrating it into a glaze.

Demi-glace has a savory flavor and a syrupy consistency and thus becomes a considerable beef consomme substitute in soups, stews, and gravies.

14. Fish Stock

Fish Stock

Fish stock is a concentrated yummy broth made by simmering fish bits, vegetables, and seasoning agents in water for hours. It doesn’t have a fishy flavor as you might think – rather, it has a well-balanced flavor profile that comprises subtle fishy flavor and flavor of vegetables and spices (of course, if prepared the right way *chuckle*).

Fish stock can be easily prepared and has a mild flavor profile making it one of the best beef consomme substitutes worth considering. 

Short Recap

That must have been an exhaustive read on the best beef consomme substitutes, right? Let me make it easy for you to remember the details with the help of some points.

Flavor: The best beef consomme substitutes in terms of flavor are beef broth, beef stock, bone broth, and beef bouillon cubes.

Consistency: The best beef consomme substitutes in terms of consistency are beef broth, beef stock, bone broth, mushroom consomme, chicken consomme, and vegetable broth.

Final Musings

Beef consomme is a nutritious and flavor-packed soup dish. Unavailability of beef consomme is not something to ruin your mood about. Instead, you can use any of the above-provided substitutes and not lose any flavor or nutrition. The list also has a few vegetarian options and works well for any occasion.

Tell me in the comments which of the beef consomme substitutes works best for you. I’ll see you next time. Until then, happy cooking!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is in beef consomme?

Beef consomme comprises beef stock, vegetables, beef, egg whites and seasoning agents.

Is beef consommé the same as beef stock?

Beef consomme and beef stock are not the same. In fact, beef stock is the base liquid that is used for making beef consomme. 

Can you substitute broth for consommé?

Consomme can be diluted with water to substitute for broth.

How do you turn beef broth into beef consomme?

By adding vegetables, beef, egg whites and suitable seasoning agents such as pepper or bay leaf to beef broth and simmering it, beef broth can be turned into beef consomme.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.