Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza Menu Prices With Calories [Updated 2025]

Famous for its coal-fired pizza and the ritual of always satisfying its customers, Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizza (also referred as ACFP) has come a long way.

You will be impressed by the wide variety of dishes on the ACFP menu and their incredibly delicious taste. Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza stands firm despite such fierce competition.

What's In The Post

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza’s Latest Menu With Prices

Summer Specials

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Mike’s Hot Honey & Burrata Pizza	$26.79	400 – 800	No	No	No	No
Burrata & Prosciutto Spaghetti	$29.19	600 – 800	No	No	No	No
Burrata & Prosciutto Sandwich	$16.99	750 – 850	No	No	No	No

Italian Shrimp Festival

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Shrimp Scampi	$15.79	269	No	No	No	No
Shrimp Scampi Spaghetti	$29.19	655	No	No	No	No
Shrimp Scampi Pizza	$26.79	659	No	No	No	No
Buffalo Shrimp Pizza	$26.79	332	No	No	No	No

Family Bundles

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	keto
16″ One Topping Pizza & 10 Wing Bundle	$43.19	2800 – 4000	No	No	No	No
16″ One Topping Pizza & Large Salad Bundle	$38.29	2250 – 3100	No	No	No	No

Starters & Salads

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Anthony’s Classic Italian Salad	$12.79	960	No	Yes	No	No
Chopped Salad	$13.99	249	No	No	Yes	No
Garlic Knots	$6.09	140	No	No	No	No
Eggplant Marino	$10.99	480	No	No	No	No
Caesar Salad	$12.79	600 – 800	No	No	No	No
Pasta Fagioli	$7.29	210	No	No	No	No
Caprese Salad	$12.79	630	No	Yes	Yes	No
Shrimp Scampi	$15.79	288	No	No	No	No
Spinach & Artichoke Dip	$15.79	290	No	No	No	No

Wings

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
5 Wings	$12.19	567	No	No	Yes	No
10 Wings	$20.69	895	No	No	Yes	No
20 Wings	$36.49	1790	No	No	Yes	No

Pizza & Meatballs

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Meatballs	$9.79	419	No	No	No	No
Burrata & Prosciutto Spaghetti	$29.19	770	No	No	No	No
Fettuccine Alfredo	$21.89	1000	No	No	No	No
Spaghetti & Meatballs	$21.89	700 – 1000	No	No	No	No
Shrimp Scampi Spaghetti	$29.19	1047	No	No	No	No

16″ Pizzas

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Create Your Own 16″ Pizza	$23.09	390 – 500	No	No	No	No
Mike’s Hot Honey 16″	$31.59	1600 – 2400	No	No	No	No
The Square Margherita 16″	$29.19	1200	No	No	No	No
Paulie’s Pie 16″	$31.59	3120 – 4000	No	No	No	No
Meatball Ricotta 16″	$31.59	2400	No	No	No	No
Carnivori 16″	$31.59	390 – 500	No	No	No	No
Caprese 16″	$29.19	1600	No	No	No	No
White 16″	$29.19	3870	No	No	No	No
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage 16″	$31.59	1500 – 2500	No	No	No	No
Eggplant Marino 16″	$29.19	2560	No	No	No	No
Roasted Cauliflower 16″	$31.59	1600 – 2400	No	No	No	No
Burrata 16″	$31.59	1134	No	No	No	No
Shrimp Scampi 16″	$31.59	540	No	No	No	No
Shrimp Alfredo 16″	$31.59	400 – 510	No	No	No	No
Buffalo Shrimp 16″	$31.59	2400 – 3600	No	No	No	No

12″ Pizzas

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Mike’s Hot Honey 12″	$26.79	800 – 1200	No	No	No	No
The Square Margherita 12″	$24.29	1120	No	No	No	No
Paulie’s Pie 12″	$26.27	390 – 500	No	No	No	No
Meatball Ricotta 12″	$26.29	1120 – 1520	No	No	No	No
Carnivori 12″	$26.79	2280	No	No	No	No
Caprese 12″	$24.29	690	No	No	No	No
White 12″	$24.29	2176	No	No	No	No
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage 12″	$26.79	1350 – 2000	No	No	No	No
Eggplant Marino 12″	$24.29	2080	No	No	No	No
Roasted Cauliflower 12″	$26.79	800 – 1500	No	No	No	No
Burrata 12″	$26.79	1200 – 1700	No	No	No	No
Shrimp Scampi 12″	$26.79	1300 – 1800	No	No	No	No
Shrimp Alfredo 12″	$26.79	400 – 600	No	No	No	No
Buffalo Shrimp 12″	$26.79	1200 – 1600	No	No	No	No

12″ Gluten Free Pizzas

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Meatball Ricotta 12″ Gluten-Free	$31.59	800 – 1200	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
White 12″ Gluten-Free	$29.19	1350	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Caprese 12″ Gluten-Free	$29.19	800 – 1200	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Carnivori 12″ Gluten-Free	$31.59	3040	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Broccoli Rabe & Sausage 12″ Gluten-Free	$31.59	800 – 1200	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Paulie’s Pie 12″ Gluten-Free	$31.59	500	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Roasted Cauliflower 12″ Gluten-Free	$31.59	800 – 1200	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Eggplant Marino 12″ Gluten-Free	$29.19	2080	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Create Your Own 12″ Gluten-Free Pizza	$23.69	1200	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Burrata 12″ Gluten-Free	$31.59	1200 – 1400	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Shrimp Scampi 12″ Gluten Free	$31.59	735	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Shrimp Alfredo 12″ Gluten Free	$31.59	800 – 1200	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Buffalo Shrimp 12″ Gluten Free	$31.59	1600 -2400	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
Mike’s Hot Honey 12″ Gluten-Free	$31.59	800 – 1200	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No
The Square Margherita 12″ Gluten-Free	$29.19	1120	No	No	Yes, but choose the toppings accordingly.	No

Sandwiches

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Long Hot Meatball Mozzarella Sandwich	$15.79	948	No	No	No	No
Coal Oven Roasted Chicken Sandwich	$16.99	325	No	No	No	No
Italian Sausage & Peppers Sandwich	$15.79	442	No	No	No	No
Chicken Broccoli Rabe Sandwich	$16.99	830	No	No	No	No
Italian Tuna Salad Sandwich	$15.79	600	No	No	No	No
Burrata Sandwich	$16.99	600	No	No	No	No

Desserts

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Mini Cannolis	$8.49	420 – 710	No	No	No	No
Tiramisu	$7.29	300 – 600	No	No	No	No
Chocolate Cake	$8.49	283 – 564	No	No	No	No
Chocolate Chip Brownie	$3.69	420	No	No	No	No
Dessert Platter	$34.09	1674	No	No	No	No
Strawberry Cake	$8.49	257	No	No	No	No
NY Cheesecake	$7.29	220- 510	No	No	No	No

Beverages

Item Name	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
Coke Can	$2.49	139	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
Diet Coke Can	$2.49	0	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Sprite Can	$2.49	39	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
Acqua Panna	$2.49	0	Nil	Nil	Nil	Nil

Party Platters

Gluten-Free	Price	Calories	Vegan	Vegetarian	Gluten-Free	Keto
(20) Meatballs	$78.99	4190	No	No	No	No
Banquet Caesar Salad	$48.69	1200	No	No	No	No
Small Pan Eggplant Marino	$70.49	1000	No	No	No	No
(50) Roasted Chicken Wings	$93.59	4475	No	No	Yes	No

Popular Items On Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza’s Menu

Meatball & Ricotta Pizza

The Meatball and Ricotta Pizza from ACFP is an explosion of flavor. On the first bite, you will want to tip the staff for being generous with the toppings.

On a fresh, out-of-oven pizza crust, you will see a soft layer of cheese and pizza sauce that somehow feels peaceful and mouth-watering.

Next, you will see baby-size meatballs looking brown and alluring on the pizza. White foamy dollops of ricotta cheese are also coated on top of them, increasing the mystery.

All in all, you will feel all the tastes: the sweetness of cheese, the tanginess of pizza sauce, and a little spicy but salty baby meatballs.

Eggplant Marino Pizza

The Eggplant Marino was born when football legend Don Marino craved eggplant parm but didn’t want to compromise his diet.

That’s what makes the Eggplant Marino a must-try for fitness enthusiasts. It will prove to you that healthy food can be extremely tasty, too.

It comes on a thin and crunchy crust on which you can clearly see the layers of pizza sauce and Romano cheese sitting calmly.

On top of that, they have put thinly sliced eggplant and Italian plum tomato sauce, looking very beautifully slathered.

The main reason it tastes tastier than our expectations is that it’s perfectly tangy, sweet, and very simple. Plus, what makes it popular, except for Don Marino, is its low-carb quality.

Pasta Fagioli

Pasta Fagioli from Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizza is a comfort food you can order whenever you sit in the blanket and enjoy a movie.

It is not just the dry pasta usually found at every other restaurant with red sauce. It is filled with the luscious goodness of special Italian plum tomatoes, bacon, and cannellini beans.

The savory taste will stay in your taste buds for a very long period, even though it will take you a long time to finish it. That is why it is the best choice of food while binging a movie in bed.

Roasted Cauliflower Pizza

This is when you realize how good cauliflower tastes on a pizza. Normally, you would make a weird face when you hear of cauliflower, and it deserves that (I think so, too).

The ACFP’s Roasted Cauliflower Pizza tastes salty, crunchy, and much more.

It comes in a square shape, topped with roasted chunks of cauliflower. This cauliflower is roasted with olive oil, and that’s exactly how it tastes—tasty! The garlic Romano and breadcrumbs sprinkled on top add a tongue-teasing salty taste.

The cheese is so warm and soft that it will flow like strings when you take a bite from your slice. Plus, you will forgive the square-shaped crust when you feel its crunch in every bite.

Chicken Broccoli Rabe Sandwich

The Chicken Broccoli Rabe Sandwich will win you over by its looks alone. It looks so fresh and clean that you might feel an irresistible urge to finish it ASAP!

It is basically a smoky, filling roasted chicken breast topped with deliciously crunchy broccoli rabe that’ll make the crunch sound in every bite.

On top of that is the mozzarella filling, which gets from the top of the sandwich to the chicken breast at the last in a matter of seconds.

Pepperoni Pizza

You will not find this item directly on Anthony Coal Fired Pizza’s menu. It is here because it is one of the most popular choices for creating your pizza. You can use many other toppings for your pizza, but I say stick with just pepperoni.

ACFP’s Pepperoni Pizza is known for its delicate taste and cheesy mess, which makes every bite heavenly. You will feel stuffed, and at the same time, you will want more pepperoni.

That’s how perfect the pepperoni feels with ACFP’s cheese and pizza sauce. They don’t even hold back on pepperoni slices, which makes it simple and best.

Caprese Salad

Caprese Salad, which I also like to call the gentleman’s dish at Anthony Coal Fired Pizzas, is beautifully organized and presented when served.

It’s so light and refreshing that you immediately agree to the salad-before-meal myth.

The prosciutto layered with olive oil tastes so good, you’ll be impressed. It would help if you tried this whenever you visit ACFP because your meal will feel incomplete without a refreshing salad anyway.

Italian Tuna Sandwich

The softness of this Italian Tuna Sandwich will make you never want to stop chewing on it. Olive oil, tomato, and Italian dressing are stuffed inside soft bread, giving this sandwich such a cushiony texture that you will become a forever customer.

I’m not even lying when I say this sandwich can alter your mood from sad to peaceful, much like music. I bet it is because they use homemade Italian Salad made with some vegetables and mostly love.

Arugula Burrata Salad

Arugula Burrata Salad from Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizzas is pure art. Oven-roasted red peppers, red onions, fresh arugula leaves, and shaved Romano cheese look messy on a plate, but the thick white burrata makes it look neat.

It’s made with fresh arugula, crunchy oven-roasted red peppers, and red onions. Then they’re tossed in homemade Italian dressing topped with fresh burrata and shaved Romano, making it a pleasure for the consumer.

Buffalo Shrimp Pizza

Buffalo Shrimp Pizza is served with hot and spicy buffalo sauce, hence the name. Moreover, it has red onions to add the perfect crisp, covered in mozzarella cheese, which adds a warm and salty taste to the onion’s sweetness.

You will also see giant pieces of soft shrimp floating in the mozzarella cheese, which go perfectly with this pizza’s crunchy crust.

Somehow, the creamy texture inside the shrimp feels more perfect when its shell is tossed in spicy sauce. The bite from this pizza will be crunchy, chewy, and mouth-filling, and the taste will remind you of Pamplona bull-run.

Carnivora

You might find Carnivora offensive to pizzas because of its appearance, so I remind you never to judge by the looks.

It is served in a square shape, and unlike five slices in a circular pizza, the Carnivora is served in twelve delightful squares. So next time you’re at ACFP with your friends’ group, you know what you’re ordering.

The taste of this pizza will make you admit that Carnivore is no less than a real pizza, or it might even be better. Moreover, it is topped with thick-cut pepperoni, Italian sausage, baby meatballs, and smoky bacon, so two to three pieces guarantee to make you feel full.

Tiramisu

Tiramisu is already a highly-rated sweet dish. Almost everybody has tried it, and I bet when you read its name, you’re nostalgic about the last Tiramisu you ate.

Just wait and give the Tiramisu served at ACFP a chance. It has a soft and light base of bread topped with Zabaione cream, which tastes perfectly sweetened.

The cocoa powder is sprinkled on top to add to the coffee taste. In short, it looks tasty, like a chocolate dessert on top of a creamy-looking base. It smells sweet and warm. Plus, it goes perfectly after any other dish you order.

What Are People Asking About Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza?

Is there a secret menu at Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza?

No, there’s no secret menu at Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza.

Does Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizza offer catering services?

Yes, Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza does offer catering services.

How many slices are in a 16” pizza?

A 16’ pizza at Anthony Coal Fired Pizza has 8 slices.

Who owns Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza?

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza is originally owned by BurgerFi international.

What are payment options available at Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza?

You can use credit, debit cards, and Apple Pay to pay online when you order from Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza.

Can you order online from Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza?

Yes, you can order pizza online using Anthony Coal Fired Pizza’s official app and website or food delivery apps like Uber Eats, Zomato, Grubhub, or Doordash.

Can you customize Anthony’s coal-fired pizza options?

Yes, you can customize the pizza items at Anthony’s Coal Fired pizza.

What are Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza’s operating hours?

Anthony’s Coal-Fired Pizza’s usual operating hours are 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Still, it is recommended that you confirm with the outlet you are curious about. This is because operating hours might vary depending on the restaurant’s location.

Current Deals Running At Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza

Currently, there are some ongoing deals at Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza.

1. Mondays (Kids Eat Free With a $10 Minimum Purchase)

This deal ia Available to children 12 and under. Kids Meals include 10″ Cheese Pizza or Kids Spaghetti & Meatballs. It is valid only on Mondays for Dine-in with a minimum $10 purchase, toppings additional charge. This cannot be combined with any other offer or reward and no substitutions.

Note: Not valid for takeout, phone, online or third party delivery orders. One kids meal per check. Participation may vary.

2. Tuesdays (20% Off Takeout With Promo Code 20OFFTUES online)

This deal is Valid only for pick up and delivery from acfp.com or the app on Tuesdays at participating locations. Guests must mention the offer to team member for phone orders to receive this special.

Must use promo code ‘20OFFTUES’ for online orders to receive discount. It is not valid for 3rd party delivery orders. One 20% discount per check.

Note: This is not valid on any family bundles, or family bundle additional toppings and modifiers.

You can also join the Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza rewards program to become a member of their family. Many offers and rewards are waiting for you to sign up.

One free 12″ pizza is just a welcome gift. The members generally earn points for every dollar spent at Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza. Moreover, you unlock many offers and deals only available to VIPs.

You should subscribe to Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza newsletter, a treasure trove of deals.

Note: If you are a VIP member of Anthony’s Coal Fired reward program, you can celebrate your birthday with a 16″ pizza of your choice. However, not being a VIP still gets you a 12″ pizza. So you can be sure that Anthony is ready to celebrate your birthday with you.

How We’ve Verified This Data?

Commitment To Quality

We at TheFoodXP ensure that we provide you with authentic information by referring you to the official website of Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza and its delivery platforms.

Cross-Verify

Even though everything in this article is based on solid facts, I suggest you confirm any additional questions with the ACFP outlet nearest to you.

Lastly If

Get deeper insights here if you want to learn more about our complete process of updating the menu prices.

Other Restaurants Menus That We’ve Covered

Conclusion

I am confident that you can get the best experience out of your ACFP experience, whether it’s your first time or you have been there before.

ACFP’s wings are known for turning people into wing addicts. In any case, I would appreciate it if you shared your experience visiting ACFP after reading this article with me in the comments.