9 Best Amaro Nonino Substitutes To Use

Amaro Nonino

Let me see. You must be a lover of cocktails, and you are here for the best Amaro Nonino substitutes. If that is the case, you must be crazy about the Paper plane cocktail. Do you know what the secret is behind that unique fruity flavor of this cocktail? It is Amaro Nonino! It is a popular liqueur used as an aperitif and digestif.

But you can’t spend your whole wallet just for a couple of shots of Amaro Nonino, right? (It’s a little pricey). So, it becomes vital to look for alternatives. Let us talk about the best substitutes for Amaro Nonino in this article. Any ideas? Well, some of the best amaro nonino substitutes are Amaro Averna, Amaro Montenegro, Amaro Ramazzotti, Cynar and Gammel Dansk.

Amaro Nonino is an Italian liqueur with a bittersweet flavor. Aged grappa is the main ingredient of this drink, along with added herbs that render a herbal flavor. It is an after-dinner drink and is a major ingredient in many holiday cocktail recipes. 

As authentic and distinctive as Amaro Nonino is, it doesn’t come to you easily. If you are on a budget, I am sure it would be worth knowing what Amaro nonino substitutes are. Read on to find out more.

Quick Peek: Amaro Nonino

Amaro Nonino

The following scribbles tell you what Amaro Nonino is, its flavor, consistency, culinary uses, and health benefits.

What Is Amaro Nonino?

Amaro Nonino or Amaro Nonino Quintessential is an Italian alcoholic beverage produced by Antonio Nonino. The word Amaro in Italian means’ bitter’. Thus, Amaro Nonino is a bittersweet liqueur usually consumed as an after-dinner drink. It is prepared using grappa, herbs, and fruits. 

Describing Amaro Nonino: Flavor and Consistency

Amaro Nonino has a distinctive, fragrant flavor that comprises mango, citrus, saffron, pepper, licorice, caramel, vanilla, and honey. With an ABV of 35% (alcohol by volume), it might be less sweet than other Amari you will find. It is also sometimes used as an aperitif. Some deem its taste similar to that of Amari Meletti and Cynar.

Uses of Amaro Nonino

Amaro Nonino has a peculiar, bittersweet flavor alongside the flavors of orange, honey, vanilla, pepper, and cocoa. You can find a perfect balance between bitterness and sweetness with hints of gentian and quinine.

Even with high alcohol content but less sweetness, Amaro nonino is relatively easy to enjoy. It is used extensively in popular cocktail recipes such as Paper plane, Amaro Nonino spritz, Black manhattan, and Amaro Nonino negroni. It is used after dinner to aid digestion. 

Amaro Nonino On The Health Radar | Looking Through The Wellness Telescope

Amaro nonino doesn’t have particularly high health benefits to boast of. It is, although a popular digestif – a drink used after dinner to enhance digestion and calm your nerves. It has 35% ABV, which means you have got to watch the quantity you consume. Moderate consumption helps you enjoy Amaro Nonino before and after a nice meal!

Why Should We Substitute Amaro Nonino?

Being an expensive chap to locate and use, it is imperative that you know about the best Amaro Nonino substitutes. In cocktail recipes where you need a little quantity of Amaro Nonino, it is unwise to buy a whole bottle of it. That’s when the best substitutes for Amaro Nonino come in handy. 

Also, why not try to be a creative bartender and find out how these substitutes work in place of Amaro Nonino? Let us know what Amaro nonino can be substituted with no further delay.

9 Best Amaro Nonino Substitutes

Now that you know everything you need to know about Amaro Nonino let us discuss the best substitutes for Amaro Nonino. The nine best substitutes for Amaro nonino are as follows:

1. Amaro Averna

Amaro Averna is an Italian liqueur made using Mediterranean herbs, spices, and fruits. It has a bittersweet flavor and a rich aroma. It is a major ingredient in many cocktail recipes. It has 29%ABV. 

Amaro Averna, basically being an amaro, is the best Amaro Nonino substitute considering its flavor profile and production process, which is similar to that of Amaro Nonino. Amaro Meletti and Amaro Tosolini are also considerable substitutes for Amaro Nonino.

2. Montenegro 


Amaro Montenegro is an Italian alcoholic beverage with 23% ABV consumed as a digestif. It is a bitter liqueur named after a princess! It has a floral and citrusy flavor and a sweet texture.

Amaro Montenegro is made using 40 herbs and thus gives out varying flavor profiles. It is precisely for this reason that it is used in many cocktail recipes. Amaro Montenegro is one of the best substitutes for Amaro nonino, considering its citrus flavor.

3. Ramazzotti


Amaro Ramazzotti is another Italian liqueur that is the oldest, original and traditional Amaro in the market. It is made using a blend of herbs, roots, and orange peels. 

With 30% ABV, it has a bitter taste and an underlying sweetness that comes with the essence of orange. Unlike Amaro Nonino, Ramazotti has a thick consistency. But the orange flavor and herbal undertones make Amaro Ramazzotti a good alternative for Amaro Nonino.

4. Cynar


A type of bitter Italian liqueur, Cynar is made from 13 herbs and plants. Artichoke (Cynara scolymus) is the dominant plant used, thus the name Cynar. It has a subtle, bittersweet flavor with citrus and chocolate notes.

With 16.5% ABV, Cynar can be used as a substitute for Amaro nonino. If you want a higher alcohol content, go for Cynar 70 to replace Amaro Nonino.

5. Gammel Dansk

Gammel Dansk

Gammel Dansk is a bitter coming to us all the way from Denmark. For those who are oblivious of bitters: bitters is an alcoholic potion made using flavored botanical extracts to counter the sweetness in cocktail recipes. Coming back to Gammel dusk, it is a highly sought-after drink made using 29 herbs and spices.

Gammel Dansk offers a range of flavors; sweet, bittersweet, spicy, and fruity. With a color akin to Amaro Nonino, Gammel Dansk is a viable option for replacing Amaro Nonino. 

6. Chartreuse


Chartreuse is a French herbal liqueur named after a monastery and mountains in France. Hailed as the ‘king of liqueurs,’ it is the only liqueur in the world with a green color. Although, it is available in yellow color as well. Chartreuse is made using 130 herbs and spices (whoa!) and has a spicy, sweet flavor with herbal overtones making it a good Amaro Nonino substitute.

Green chartreuse has an ABV of 55%, while Yellow chartreuse has an ABV of 40%. While choosing to replace, be cautious to consider the intensity and color of these substitutes.

7. Vermouth


Vermouth is nothing but a fortified wine that is flavored with roots, barks, flowers, seeds, herbs, and spices. Vermouth is served as an aperitif and is used in various cocktail recipes. It may not be a good substitute for Amaro nonino because it is, foremost, a wine. But looking at the flavor profile Vermouth possesses, it can be considered a substitute for Amaro Nonino.

Two types of vermouth are available; dry and sweet. Dry vermouth has a fruity flavor with herbal undertones. Sweet vermouth has the flavor of vanilla and caramel. Thus, vermouth has a taste profile depending on its type.

8. Bonal Gentiane Quina

Bonal Gentiane-Quina

Fondly called ‘oeuvre l’appétit’ (key to appetite), Bonal gentiane quina is made using herbs like gentian and cinchona bark in a fortified wine base. It has an intense fruity flavor with a spicy, herbal finish.

Bonal Gentiane Quina looks dark brown and has a flavor very similar to sweet vermouth and other Amari liqueurs which makes it a good choice as an alternative to Amaro nonino.

9. Angostura Bitters

Angostura Bitters

Angostura bitters is a type of bitters with an ABV of 47%. First produced in Venezuela, these concentrated bitters have a spicy flavor with notes of cinnamon and clove. 

Angostura Bitters is a highly concentrated food and beverage flavoring agent. Considering Amaro Nonino has pepper and anise in it, Angostura bitters can be one of the alternatives worth trying.

Short Recap For Best Amaro Nonino Substitutes

That must have been an exhaustive read on the best Amaro Nonino substitutes, right? Let me make it easy for you to remember the details with the help of some points.

Amaro-based Substitutes: The best Amaro Nonino substitutes which are Amaro are Amaro Averna, Amaro Meletti, Amaro Tosolini, Amaro Montenegro, and Amaro Ramazotti.

Other Options: The other best Amaro Nonino substitutes are Cynar, Gammel Dansk, Chartreuse, Vermouth, Bonal Gentiane Quina, and Angostura Bitters.

Final Musings

I have made the task of finding substitutes for Amaro nonino quite easy for you. Do you know how you should thank me? Try them out and tell me which substitute worked the best in the comments. Come back to read more of my readable scribbles.

I have made the task of finding substitutes for Amaro nonino quite easy for you. Do you know how you should thank me? Try them out and tell me which substitute worked the best in the comments. Come back to read more of my readable scribbles.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What does Amaro Nonino taste like?

Amaro Nonino has a bittersweet flavor – a perfect balance between bitterness and sweetness with hints of gentian and quinine.

What is an Amaro Nonino substitute in Paper Plane?

Amaro Montenegro is a good substitute for Amaro Nonino in Paper Plane.

What do you use an Amaro Nonino for?

Amaro Nonino is a popular ingredient in several cocktails such as Fly-By-Knight, Amaro Paisano, White Oak Propeller andThe Italian American Cocktail.

What is in a paper plane cocktail?

The ingredients in a paper plane cocktail are bourbon, Aperol, Amaro Nonino Quintessentia and lemon juice.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.