9 Knockoff Whataburger Recipes

Do you know Whataburger turned 70 a year ago? Yes, you read that right. Whataburger has been operational for 70 years now. For Texans, it is a unique and leading fast-food chain. This legendary fast-food chain of restaurants makes it one of a kind. 

All the Whataburger recipes

Besides being the top choice of Texans, the chain is well-known for serving up sizable hamburgers, breakfast, and much more. The famished folks look forward to grabbing a bite at any time from Whataburger. If you are looking to chow down your favorite meals from Whataburger, I have good news for you! 

You can prepare all your favorite meals in no time. Endeavor these dishes with variations, an assortment of toppings, and burger combinations straight in your kitchen. Don’t panic, I am surely going to help you with the copycat recipes. Before we continue with the recipes, let me shed some light on the history. 

Whataburger was founded by Harmon Dobson on August 8, 1950. With 70 years in business, the food chain has become a fan-favorite. Presently, it is owned by the Chicago Company, BDT Capital Partners. The iconic brand has flourished to a large extent. Let’s know more. 

Being one of the most prominent fast-food chains, Whataburger’s menu offers special food items to be prepared on Easter. These dishes are Honey BBQ chicken strip sandwiches, honey butter chicken biscuit, patty melt, and Original Whataburger. Try some of them this Easter and be grateful. 

Today we have covered some of the best knockoff recipes from Whataburger menu. These recipes are easy to make in no time. With the basic pantry staples, you can prepare these recipes at home. Save yourself a trip to the restaurant and prepare these recipes with us. 

1. Whataburger Monterey Melt 

Monterey melt with beef patty and oozing cheese

Whataburger Monterey melt is an enticing burger filled with flavorful toppings. Loaded with seasoned patties, veggies, ranch sauce, and oozing cheese, the Monterey melt tastes exquisitely delicious. The best part is that the homemade appetizing Monterey melt will be ready in a flick. 

The key to making savory Monterey melt is to grill the seasoned patties, whisk in to make ranch sauce, and saute the veggies. Season the ground beef with dry rubs like garlic powder, onion powder, salt, and pepper. Combine the mixture using hands and form a round-shaped patty.

Separately, combine mayonnaise, buttermilk, cilantro, jalapenos, minced garlic, and ranch seasoning. The ranch sauce will be ready. Saute the veggies until they are translucent and cooked through. 

Club the burger sandwich with the grilled patty, veggies, and ranch dressing. Pull off a last-minute breakfast like an expert with this copycat Monterey melt at home. For the full recipe, just click here!

2. Whataburger Patty Melt 

patty melt with flavorful beef patties and crispy onions

A hearty and tempting burger that satiates your cravings is the one and only Whataburger patty melt. The good part about this burger sandwich is that it is prepared using Texas toast. The Texas toast tastes great and is easily available in the nearby supermarkets. Let’s dig deep to know the recipe!

To prepare the patty melt, you need ground beef, caramelized onions, garlic powder, salt, and black pepper. Combine the beef with the dry mixture and form a round-shaped patty. Grill two patties, caramelize the onions by dipping them into the buttermilk and then deep-fry until crispy. 

To club the patty melt, layer the bottom bun with the sauce. Place the patties on top, followed by crispy onions. Drizzle a teaspoon of sauce on the top and cover it to serve. I have added a link for the full recipe for Whataburger patty melt. Click and see it yourself!

3. Whataburger Creamy Pepper Sauce

Homemade pepper sauce

Whataburger creamy pepper sauce is a tempting sauce prepared with the right amount of flavor and spicy kick. The steps for making this sauce are quite simple. Want to know how to prepare a fresh batch of creamy pepper sauce? Scroll down. 

The sauce recipes are so feasible to get done right. With just a whisk, the sauce will be ready. The recipe for creamy pepper sauce goes like this: combine mayonnaise, mustard powder, chipotle peppers in adobo sauce, white vinegar, smoked paprika, onion powder, ground white pepper, garlic powder, and lemon juice. 

Whisk until smooth and creamy. The replicate peppery sauce will be ready. Garnish the sauce with fresh parsley and serve with your favorite dishes. If you wish to check out the complete recipe, follow the link. 

4. Whataburger Spicy Ketchup

Colorful spicy ketchup in a jar

Are you ready to yield perfect flavorsome spicy sharpness with Whataburger spicy ketchup? If yes, then you have come to the right place. This spicy ketchup is packed with a sweet and savory blend of flavors that tastes heavenly. You will surely relish the tangy palate of dishes served with spicy ketchup. 

To get this spicy ketchup ready in your kitchen, all you have to do is simmer the jalapenos and combine them with other elements. Strain off the excess water from boiled jalapenos. Blend it with tomato paste, white vinegar, water, honey, cinnamon, cayenne pepper, ground cloves, and salt. 

Blend the mixture until it is soft and smooth. Strain the mixture using a mesh strainer and simmer for about 5 minutes. When the mixture is thickened, turn off the heat. Allow spicy ketchup to cool down before you go ahead and serve! Let me make it easier for you; click to check out the full recipe with details. 

5. Whataburger Dr. Pepper shake 

Dr Pepper Shake Topped With Whipped Cream

Treat your taste buds with an amazing shake offered at Whataburger. It is none other than a Dr. Pepper shake. Whataburger Dr. Pepper shake is filled with incredible flavors and prepared with just a handful of elements. If you are already parched, then follow the recipe of this knockoff pepper shake. 

All you need is a Dr. Pepper drink, vanilla ice cream, and ice cubes. As the pepper shake and vanilla ice cream already had a sugar content, we didn’t add any more to it. In a saucepan, simmer the Dr. Pepper drink until it thickens. Moving forward, blend vanilla ice cream, Dr. Pepper drink, and ice cubes. 

When it is blended, serve and enjoy! Seek out the required list of equipment, ingredients, nutritional facts, and instructions. The full recipe is just a click away!

6. Whataburger Mushroom Swiss Burger

Juicy mushroom and beef patty with oozing cheese

The swiss mushroom burger is the latest burger added to the Whataburger menu. It is packed with pulsed mushrooms, grilled beef patties, swiss cheese, and rich spices. Mimic the remarkable Whataburger flavors in your kitchen. Keep reading to know more. 

Initially, pulse the mushrooms and merge them with the ground beef. Season this ground mixture with some dry rubs to form a round-shaped patty. Grill the patties until crispy and golden brown. Simultaneously, toast the hamburger buns. Finally, assemble the burger when things have fallen right in place. 

Place a Swiss cheese slice on the bottom bun and microwave to melt the cheese. Pour a teaspoon of Au Jus sauce on the bottom bun, and place the grilled patties, followed by fresh lettuce, caramelized onions, and mushrooms. Cover the swiss burger with the top bun, and it is ready to serve. Click for the full recipe!

7. Whataburger Honey Butter

Honey drizzled on the top of butter

Whataburger honey butter comes together in a flick. Prepared with honey, vanilla extract, and butter, it tastes delicious. The recipe to make this honey butter is facile. Don’t believe what I am saying; read more to see it yourself. 

In a bowl, add softened butter, a teaspoon of vanilla extract, and honey. Combine everything to achieve a smooth and soft texture of the honey butter. A combination of sweet honey, creamy butter, and a splash of vanilla extract is what makes this honey butter distinctive and delicious. 

Follow the instructions mentioned in the full recipe article. Don’t panic; the link for the recipe is here. You will find the notable list of equipment, ingredients, calorific value, and instructions to make Whataburger honey butter. 

8. Whataburger Gravy 

Whataburger gravy poured on the top of biscuits

For all the pressing gravy questions, the answer is Whataburger gravy. A little pot of creamy, thick, and glossy gravy is pleasant and satiates your cravings. Don’t settle for lumpy or unsavory gravy in your kitchen. Incorporate the perfect flavors of gravy with us. 

Melt the butter over medium heat in a saucepan. Then, add flour, salt, thyme, black pepper, and cayenne pepper. Simmer for around 5 minutes and then pour milk, frequently stirring, into the saucepan. Bring the gravy to a proper boil until it is creamy and reduced to half. 

Achieve the right consistency with our recipe article. It includes all the tips and tricks you need to follow. Skip going to the restaurant and make a knockoff version of Whataburger gravy at home. The recipe with the details is just a click away!

9. Whataburger Seasoning 

Homemade seasoning

Spice up your life and your food with a fan-favorite Whataburger seasoning. Toss the dry rubs, and the replicated Whataburger seasoning will be ready in the blink of an eye. Prepared with homemade dry rubs, this copycat seasoning is more nutritious than store packets. 

Add a teaspoon of smoked paprika, salt, black pepper, brown sugar, garlic powder, onion powder, cayenne pepper, and accent seasoning. The accent seasoning added to this seasoning recipe enhances the flavor. Stir in all the elements of seasoning, and you are good to go. 

It takes only 5 minutes to put together all the elements, and the seasoning will be ready. Have a quick look at the full recipe of Whataburger seasoning by following the link. You will find the notable list of required equipment, ingredients, nutritional facts, and instructions in the article. 


Endeavor to prepare the Whataburger recipes at home and share them with your loved ones. Get ready to be amazed by replicating the flavors right in your kitchen. Among these best recipes, choose your top favorites and add them to the culinary list. For the details, follow the recipe guide in the above article. Moreover, don’t forget to share your tweaks with us in the comment section below. Happy cooking!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *